05/12/2026
November 1, 1943: USS Borie (DD-215), a World War II destroyer, engaged German submarine U-405 in the most savage naval battle of the Atlantic War. This is the true story of when an American warship rammed a U-boat, landed on top of it, and crews fought hand-to-hand with knives, shotguns, and thrown shell casings in the North Atlantic.
THE INCREDIBLE TRUE STORY:
Lieutenant Charles Hutchins, a Naval Academy graduate who quit the Navy to run a packing company in Indiana, commanded the 23-year-old destroyer Borie during a 64-minute death match against Korvettenkapitän Rolf-Heinrich Hopman's U-405. When the destroyer accidentally landed on top of the submarine during ramming, both crews fought at distances of 10-15 feet in medieval-style close quarters combat while locked together in 20-foot waves.
The battle ended with U-405 sinking with all 49 hands. But when Borie attempted to rescue 14 German survivors in life rafts, sonar detected incoming torpedoes. Commander Hutchins faced an impossible choice: save enemy sailors or protect his 156-man crew. He chose his crew, running directly through the rafts. The next day, Borie sank during rescue operations, killing 27 Americans—making this a double tragedy where both ships were lost.
KEY MOMENTS:
0:00 - The Ramming: Destroyer Lands on Submarine
2:00 - Commander Charles Hutchins: From Businessman to Naval Hero
6:00 - First Contact: Radar Detection and Depth Charge Attack
10:00 - Close Combat: Fighting with Knives and Shotguns
15:00 - The Impossible Choice: German Survivors in the Water
20:00 - Borie Sinks: 27 American Deaths During Rescue
25:00 - Navy Cross Awards and Presidential Unit Citation
30:00 - Legacy: Why This Battle Changed Naval Warfare
FEATURED IN THIS DOCUMENTARY:
USS Borie DD-215 Clemson-class destroyer specifications and history
German U-405 Type VIIC submarine capabilities
Lieutenant Charles H. Hutchins biography and command decisions
Lieutenant Morrison R. Brown's heroic sacrifice in flooded engine room
Fire Controlman Robert Maher's eyewitness account (author of "Sailors' Journey into War")
Task Group 21.14 operations under Captain Arnold J. Isbell
North Atlantic convoy battles and U-boat wolf pack tactics
World War II submarine warfare technology and strategy
Presidential Unit Citation ceremony aboard USS Card
Navy Cross recipients and Medal of Honor considerations
40-foot waves and hypothermia conditions during rescue
USS Goff and USS Barry rescue operations
Post-war analysis and naval tactical doctrine changes
HISTORICAL CONTEXT:
Battle of the Atlantic 1943, German Kriegsmarine operations, American destroyer tactics, antisubmarine warfare, es**rt carrier task groups, depth charge attacks, surface gun battles, ramming tactics, law of the sea, prisoner rescue protocols, combat decision-making under fire, WWII naval engagements, North Atlantic weather conditions, torpedo evasion, scuttling procedures, abandon ship operations, cold water survival, maritime rescue disasters.
CASUALTIES:
U-405: 49 killed (all hands lost including commander)
USS Borie: 27 killed during rescue (0 killed in battle)
Total: 76 men died across both vessels
AWARDS & RECOGNITION:
Presidential Unit Citation, Navy Cross (3 recipients), Silver Star (2 recipients), German Cross in Gold (Hopman, posthumous), U.S. Naval Institute Distinguished Author Award (Robert Maher, 1998)
SUCCESSOR SHIPS:
USS Borie DD-704 fought at Iwo Jima, Okinawa, Korean War, Cuban Missile Crisis, and Vietnam War before transfer to Argentine Navy as ARA Hipólito Bouchard.
SOURCES:
"Sailors' Journey into War" by Robert A. Maher and James E. Wise Jr., U.S. Naval Institute archives, National Archives action reports, "Duel in the Deep" by David L. Sears, official Navy records, eyewitness testimonies, German naval archives.
This World War 2 documentary explores themes of military leadership, impossible moral choices, naval combat history, submarine warfare, destroyer tactics, survival stories, heroism under fire, and the human cost of war
Subscribe for more untold stories from WWII, and military history. New historical documentaries every week covering naval battles, air combat, ground warfare, and the extraordinary people who shaped history.