Homes by Natashia Bontrager, Realtor

09/21/2026

5.0 star review received on Experience.com for Homes by Natashia Bontrager, Realtor by Cheryl W - I want to say that Natashia was the absolute best realtor I have ever worked with. She is so friendly and listens to your specific needs and wants. She follows up immediately with a text or phone call when I had questions. I would highly recommend her to anyone needing a realtor!

Click to see all 14 reviews of Homes by Natashia Bontrager, Realtor, Broker

08/17/2026

🏡 JUST LISTED IN WARSAW!

📍 3703 W Old Road 30

Set on approximately 1.15 acres, this 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom ranch offers 100 feet of frontage and direct access to the Tippecanoe River. Whether you enjoy kayaking, canoeing, fishing, boating, or simply relaxing by the water, this property gives you plenty of ways to enjoy the outdoors. 🛶🎣

Inside, the easy one-level layout features comfortable living spaces, updated flooring, and a sunroom filled with natural light.

Showings are officially open! Contact me today for more information or to schedule your private showing.

📲 574-202-2752

08/15/2026

🏡 JUST LISTED!

📍1812 Columbia St., South Bend

This beautifully remodeled home is ready for its new owner! Featuring 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, main-level laundry, and plenty of flexible living space.

✨ Highlights include:

• Beautifully remodeled kitchen with appliances included
• New siding, metal roof, windows, flooring, lighting, and garage door
• Two bedrooms on the main level
• Third bedroom upstairs with a large loft and bonus room
• Updated bathroom
• Barn-door kitchen pantry
• Covered front porch
• Detached one-car garage with a new metal roof
• Basement with a new sump pump and extra storage

Nothing left to do but unpack and move in! Contact me today for more information or to schedule your private showing. 🔑

📲 574-202-2752

08/14/2026

Just Sold! 🎉 Congratulations to my sellers on the successful closing of 1333 N Meade St.!

This one came with a few bumps, including a lower-than-expected appraisal. I advocated for my clients, pushed for a second appraisal, kept the transaction moving, and got the job done—all while handling the stress behind the scenes for them.

Having the right agent in your corner matters. It’s about more than opening doors and completing paperwork. It’s about representation, problem-solving, and being a buffer when issues arise.

It’s always a pleasure working with another loyal investor client who has trusted me for several years. Thank you for continuing to trust me to look out for you and help secure the best possible outcome. Congratulations again! 🏡🔑

Thinking about buying, selling, or investing? I would be happy to help!

08/07/2026

July was BUSY & BLESSED! ❤️

So thankful for all of my amazing clients who trusted me to be part of their buying and selling journeys!

A huge thank you to my friends, family, past clients, and everyone who continues to support my business and send referrals my way.

Congratulations to all of my July buyers & sellers! 🥂🏡

07/18/2026

Happy Birthday ! Wishing you a beautiful day filled with all of your favorite things!

07/14/2026

New Listing in South Bend 🏡

717 Lincolnway E is now available!

This all-brick duplex is a great opportunity for an investor looking to add to their portfolio. Both units are currently occupied, with rental income already in place.

Offered at $139,900

Lease agreements, T-12s, and management statements are available upon request. Tenants’ rights apply, and showings do require at least 24 hours’ notice.

For more information, call or text me anytime. ☎ 574-202-2752

07/13/2026

Congratulations to the Jamerson's! 🥰

This one is really special to me.

I’ve had the privilege of working with the Jamerson's for the past four years, and somewhere along the way, they became so much more than clients. They became like family to me.

Mr. Jamerson is a veteran, pastor, mentor, man of faith, devoted husband, and someone who has served his congregation, his family, and his community well.

Mrs. Jamerson is a wonderful wife, mother, and daughter, with such a heart for her family and others. She is also a dedicated member of the South Bend School Corporation, and someone I truly admire.

It has been such an honor to help them through this journey and to share so many stories, laughs, and conversations along the way. I’m grateful for the trust, friendship, and kindness they’ve shown me over the years.

Congratulations on this next chapter. I wish you both all the best and will always be thankful our paths crossed.

Natashia Bontrager
McKinnies Realty
574-202-2752

06/29/2026

🏡✨ This one may go down as the easiest sale to date. I put the sign in the yard, and a buyer called moments later with a cash offer. Sometimes things really do fall into place exactly how they’re supposed to.

What started as a friendship with my mechanic has turned into a few purchases, a few sales, and now a friend for life. I’m so thankful for the trust and faith you’ve had in me over the years.

He is now off to a southern state to continue building his dreams, developing homes, a ranch, and chasing the next chapter. I couldn’t be happier for him.

Congratulations, LaWayne! Thank you for your friendship, your trust, and for letting me be a part of your journey. I wish you nothing but the best and can’t wait to see what the future holds for you.

Just Sold — 51930 County Road 9, Elkhart

06/29/2026

Yahoo! 🥳 Congratulations to my seller client on the successful closing of this property!

It was such an honor to help another hardworking, dedicated teacher and investor through the selling process. As a Homes for Heroes Realtor®, one of my favorite parts of this work is being able to give back to those who serve our communities every day.

Teachers pour so much into others, and it means a lot to be able to serve them in return.

If you or someone you know deserves a reward for buying or selling a home, I would love to help. Call me anytime to learn more about the Homes for Heroes program and how it may benefit you.

Natashia Bontrager
McKinnies Realty
Homes for Heroes Realtor®
574-202-2752