08/21/2026
Sterling Point is fictional… but this Muskoka island isn’t. 🌊
The hit series has everyone dreaming about summers spent boating, swimming and escaping to an island in Muskoka—but what is the real waterfront market doing?
At the end of July, Muskoka had 537 active waterfront listings, the highest July inventory in nine years. Buyers have more choice, but prices haven’t collapsed—the median waterfront sale price is only 1.8% lower than last year.
The real story is pricing.
The waterfront properties that sold moved in a median of just 21 days and achieved approximately 95% of their final asking price. Meanwhile, more waterfront listings expired or were cancelled this year than actually sold.
Translation? Buyers are active, but they’re selective—and they aren’t overpaying.
If Sterling Point has you dreaming about island life, meet 23 Taylor Island, offered at $1,470,000.
It’s a little more upscale than Annie and Ramona’s cabin, with:
✨ Three-bedroom cottage
✨ Separate guest cabin
✨ Approximately two acres
✨ Roughly 300 feet of waterfront
✨ Transferable mainland boat slip
✨ Potential for a two-slip boathouse
✨ A marina conveniently close by
Your Sterling Point summer doesn’t have to stay on the screen.
Comment ISLAND or message me for the full listing—and send this Reel to the person you’d bring with you. 🚤
Mandie Charlton
RE/MAX Professionals North
705-571-9777
Let me get you SOLD on Muskoka.
IslandLife PrivateIsland MuskokaRealtor WaterfrontRealEstate CottageCountry remax