09/10/2026
September 2026 Niagara & St. Catharines Market Outlook
Summer is wrapping up, so let’s look at where the Niagara real estate market actually stands heading into the fall.
And there’s one number I want you to remember.
Six months.
That’s approximately how much housing inventory we’re now carrying across Niagara.
Earlier this summer we were closer to five months.
That shift matters.
Regional sales are down approximately 4.6%, while the average sale price has adjusted about 4.5%.
We’re not looking at a market where people have stopped buying.
We’re looking at a market where buyers have more leverage.
And St. Catharines tells an interesting story.
Through August, 1,055 homes have sold, approximately 6% fewer than last year.
The average sale price is now around $577,000, down approximately 7% year over year.
So prices have adjusted a little more than sales activity.
To me, that says buyers are still there.
They’re simply more selective about what they’re willing to pay.
So what does that mean if you’re buying?
You finally have options.
More inventory means more properties to compare.
There’s often more negotiating room.
And depending on the property, you may be able to include financing, inspection and other reasonable conditions.
But don’t mistake leverage for permission to throw lowball offers at everything.
Good homes still attract attention.
Your job isn’t to get the biggest discount.
Your job is to identify the right property at the right value.
What about sellers?
This is where strategy becomes critical.
Six months of inventory means your home has competition.
Today’s buyer can open their phone and compare your property against every competing listing in seconds.
If you’re overpriced, they’ll know.
If your presentation is poor, they’ll know.
And if you’ve reduced the price three times, they’ll know that too.
That’s why I believe September listings need sharper pricing from day one.
Your first couple of weeks are incredibly valuable.
Don’t waste them testing a price the market isn’t willing to support.
And then there are rightsizers.
This may actually be one of the most interesting groups in today’s market.
If you’re moving up, the larger home you’re buying may have fallen by more dollars than the home you’re selling.
If you’re downsizing, more inventory gives you time to find something that actually improves your lifestyle rather than simply buying what’s available.
Maybe that’s a bungalow.
Maybe it’s less property maintenance.
Maybe it’s freeing up equity.
Maybe it’s finally getting the freedom to lock the door and travel.
That’s why I prefer the word rightsizing.
It’s not necessarily about buying something smaller.
It’s about buying something that fits the next chapter of your life better.
So what’s my outlook for this fall?
I expect buyers to maintain negotiating leverage.
I expect properly priced homes to continue selling.
And I expect overpriced listings to have a difficult time.
I don’t see that as bad news.
I see a market that’s becoming more rational.
And rational markets create opportunities for people who understand the numbers.
If you’re thinking about buying, selling, moving up or rightsizing this fall, don’t try to perfectly time the market.
Figure out whether this market can work to your advantage.
Those are two very different questions.
I’m Michael Sommer.
Let me help you love where you live.