05/14/2026
🚨 Historic Beaux Arts Landmark For Sale at a NEW PRICE! 🚨
Listed by CASEY VAN DER MAREL
200 Main Street East, Hamilton, Ontario
👉19,600+ square feet
👉Lot size: 103 ft x 140 ft
👉Zoning: D1
Price: $1,499,900.00
First Pilgrim United Church is a well maintained Beaux Arts institutional property prominently located in Hamilton’s downtown core. Constructed in 1912, the building showcases an impressive architectural presence with its symmetrical facade, six full height Corinthian columns, and classic stone detailing. Offering nearly 20,000 sq ft of usable space across the main level mezzanine and finished basement, the property provides a highly functional and versatile layout. The bright and spacious sanctuary was substantially updated as part of extensive building wide renovations completed in 1984. It features beautiful woodwork, stained glass elements, an organ loft, and an upper balcony with additional seating and an integrated audio visual booth overlooking the main hall. The building includes a full gymnasium and hall, a commercial style kitchen, multiple offices, reception areas, meeting rooms, and a functioning elevator servicing the main and lower level. Most of the current expenses are covered by a portion of the lower level and various other rooms currently leased, generating approximately $6,900 in monthly income. Positioned along a major downtown corridor, the property offers excellent visibility and easy access to public transportation. With its generous square footage, strong architectural character, and well maintained condition, this landmark building is suited for continued institutional use or a wide range of future redevelopment possibilities.
For More Information:
📞 905-664-7900
MLS® #: 40829574
