23/10/2020
Why does the government want to phase out gas cookers and boilers? Gas produces nitrous oxide and carbon monoxide when it burns. A modern gas boiler is extremely well ventilated and has a balanced flue, drawing air from outside the building into the boiler and expelling the air from the boiler outside of the building, through 2 different holes in the wall. With a gas cooker this is too difficult but you still probably have some ventilation. A passive vent, or maybe two, would have been fitted in the room to help restore breathable air. When you're boiling a pan on a gas stove, the gas flame is right in front of your face. This is probably all right, as you are only burning a small amount of gas. It is rare to get carbon monoxide poisoning if the cooker is installed correctly.
Why is gas controversial? Carbon monoxide poisoning is the worst case scenario. The person would be taken away in an ambulance. But now we're starting to worry more about how low levels of gases like nitrous oxide and carbon monoxide effect our health. What effect do these fumes have on asthma? Are they carcinogenic? Gas has the obvious advantage of being a directly burning fuel. An electric cooker or boiler has to be attached to a power station and a traditional coal fired power station is only 35% efficient. A modern gas boiler might be 89% efficient. But gas produces more of these particulates - more of these noxious fumes that can often aggravate childhood asthma considerably or possibly cause cancer. It produces them either inside, in the case of the cooker, or immediately outside the home, in the case of a modern boiler flue. At least a gas fired power station can be several miles from the city. The government have also been replacing a lot of the old coal fired power stations with nuclear power stations and a significant proportion of electricity is generated from renewables. The new heat pumps are also a lot more efficient than a traditional immersion heater or electric boiler. This makes electricity more environmentally friendly. This is why the government want large housing developments, in the future, to be off the gas grid and electrically heated.