10/07/2026
🏠 Would you buy this Quincy two-family for $869,000?
Here’s what the current public listing shows:
💰 Asking price: $869K
🏘️ 2-family property
💵 Reported rent: $4,200/month
📅 Gross income: $50,400/year
🏛️ Property tax: $8,131/year
At first glance, it might look like a solid Boston-area rental.
But I ran a more conservative rental analysis.
Using estimated allowances for vacancy, repairs, capital reserves, management, and insurance:
📊 Estimated NOI: ~$26,700/year
📉 Estimated cap rate: ~3.1%
Then I added example financing:
25% down
7% interest
30-year loan
Estimated debt payments: ~$52,000/year
That means the current rent wouldn’t come close to covering the projected debt service.
❌ My call: PASS as a traditional long-term rental at the current income.
But that doesn’t automatically mean “bad property.”
A buyer might instead explore:
🏡 Owner-occupant / house hack
🛠️ Value-add improvements
📈 Verified opportunity to raise rents
💰 A much lower negotiated purchase price
The important question isn’t just:
“Is this a good property?”
It’s:
“Does this property work for my strategy at this price?”
What would you do?
Pass, negotiate, house hack, or value-add?
Public listing reviewed October 7, 2026. Expense and financing figures are estimates for discussion and should be verified before any investment decision.
For reference, the current public listing information is available through Zillow’s 165 Whitwell St listing and Compass’s current listing.