Laurel Lustgarten-Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

Home
United States
Central Valley, NY
Laurel Lustgarten-Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

"Committed, Accessible, Dependable"
Servicing all areas of Orange County and portions of Sullivan Laurel Lustgarten has been a full-time realtor since 2003.

Her high level of energy, enthusiasm, and market knowledge is the perfect combination to bring a successful outcome whether you are buying or selling a home. Having built a reputation for client satisfaction, Laurel is devoted to providing service beyond your expectations. In July 2018 she had the thrill of being selected as a top realtor in the Reader's Choice "Best of the Best" Awards! This contest is sponsored by the Times Herald-Record and starts with a public nomination, followed by an online round of voting for the top six real estate agents down to the top three... and the announcement she was chosen number one! What a special and humbling recognition! The year ended with Laurel being selected to be amongst an elite group of real estate professionals recognized as America's Top 100 Real Estate Agents. The following year ended with another recognition to this elite national group. Not an easy award to achieve once but even harder to place two years in a row! Laurel's commitment to her business and to her clients also recently caught the attention of a national television network and she had the privilege of being featured in an episode of House Hunters on HGTV. This was the first time the show was filmed in the Hudson Valley. Neither Laurel nor her buyer clients will ever forget this experience and the show is still airing in reruns! In fact, there may be another episode in her future...

Real Estate is one of the most exciting and rewarding investments you can make. Selecting the right real estate professional is crucial. Laurel's "hands-on" approach, industry expertise, and client-oriented focus yield outstanding results! Real estate transactions can be challenging, but with Laurel on your side you know you will receive special care and attention from the beginning of the process to the day she accompanies you to the closing table.

09/23/2026

💚 Celebrating 15 Years with Rand Realty! 💚

As I celebrate this company milestone, I can’t help but reflect on the bigger picture. I’m just shy of 23 years in real estate and the years have flown by, even if they’ve been filled with some very longgggg days! 🤣

Nearly 23 years of helping people buy and sell homes, navigating the ups and downs of the market, building relationships and still always having “just when I thought I’ve seen it all” moments! And 15 of those years have been with a company that has become such an important part of my professional and personal life.

I’m so grateful for my Rand family - the colleagues who have become some of my closest friends and those who have supported and encouraged me, making this career all the more rewarding.

And to my clients, past and present, thank you for your trust, your referrals and the opportunity to be part of so many important chapters in your lives. You are the reason I love what I do!

Here’s to the experiences, the lessons, the friendships and all that’s still ahead! 🥂

📲 914-443-2246
📧 [email protected]
👩‍💻 Laurellustgarten.randrealty.com

09/17/2026

🚨 NEW PRICE! $15,000 PRICE REDUCTION!
If you’ve been watching this property, now may be the time to make a move!

With 6.1 acres and approximately 4,100 square feet of finished space, including the finished basement, this home offers the kind of space, flexibility and privacy that’s hard to find.

✨ Spacious, flexible floorplan 🔥 Family room with vaulted wood ceiling and stone fireplace 🛏️ First-floor primary suite and second primary suite upstairs 🌳 6.1 private, park-like acres 🌿 Expansive deck

Located in the Monroe-Woodbury School District with easy access to NYC transportation, highways and Hudson Valley attractions.

214 W. Mombasha Road, Monroe, NY
4 Bedrooms | 2.5 Bathrooms | $782,000

📲 914-443-2246
📧 [email protected]
👩‍💻 Laurellustgarten.randrealty.com

09/10/2026

SOLD in Scotchtown! 🏡❤️

There’s something extra special about helping to sell a home right here in my own neighborhood. I’m proud to live here and always appreciate the opportunity to represent sellers in my own backyard.

My meticulous clients poured so much pride, care and attention into this home and it showed in every corner. They loved this house - and it was one of the most admired homes. I’m so grateful they trusted me to help them get it ready, position it well and ultimately achieve a result they could feel really good about.

And what a result it was: $10,000 over asking and the highest sale price for a Scotchtown home in years!

A big thank you to Juan Bautista for being such a pleasure to work with and for making this a smooth transaction from start to finish.

Congratulations to my sellers and to the new owners. I’m so happy to see it begin its next chapter.

📲 914-443-2246
📧 [email protected]
👩‍💻 laurellustgarten.randrealty.com

08/25/2026

SOLD and this one is extra special. ❤️

After 41 years of loving the home they built, these original owners were ready to begin their next chapter. I’m so grateful they trusted me to help them turn the page.

They listened to every recommendation, put in the work needed to prepare their home and together we created a plan that truly paid off. Within just days of hitting the market, we received 11 offers and ultimately sold for $81,000 over asking - 115% of list price!

But the outcome is only part of the story. The best part was working with genuinely wonderful sellers who cared so deeply about their home. They were landscaping, vacuuming the pool and washing windows even as the movers packed their belongings. I admired their pride, care and commitment more than they know, and feel so fortunate to have been part of their journey.

Here’s to new beginnings for my sellers and many wonderful memories ahead for the new owners.

📲 914-443-2246
📧 [email protected]
👩‍💻 laurellustgarten.randrealty.com

08/20/2026

🏡 Resort-style living in the Greens of Woodbury!

This stately one-owner colonial offers beautifully maintained living space, with a private backyard that truly steals the show.

✨ Stunning inground pool
✨ Expansive paver patio + pergola
✨ Beautifully landscaped and hardscaped grounds
✨ Spacious eat-in kitchen with gas range
✨ Vaulted family room with marble-faced fireplace
✨ 4 bedrooms + main-level study/guest room
✨ Generous primary suite
✨ Whole-house Generac + irrigation + reverse osmosis

Located in the Monroe-Woodbury School District and close to NYC transportation, major highways, shopping, dining and Hudson Valley attractions.

A home that checks all the boxes - and gives you a backyard that feels like a getaway. 🏡

44 Greenwich Avenue | Central Valley, NY

4 Bedrooms | 3 Bathrooms | $887,000

📲 914-443-2246
📧 [email protected]
👩‍💻 Laurellustgarten.randrealty.com

08/10/2026

🏡 Room to live, space to grow and a place to call home.

Set in an established Village of Walden neighborhood, this spacious raised ranch offers the location, updates and flexibility you’ve been looking for.

✨ Two levels of comfortable living space
✨ New flooring and light fixtures
✨ Open kitchen with stainless steel appliances
✨ Primary suite with walk-in closet and direct bath access
✨ Lower level with family room, guest room and full bath
✨ Beautifully crafted paver walkway, patio and steps
✨ Expansive deck overlooking a large, fully fenced backyard
✨ Laundry room with brand-new washer & dryer
✨ Two-car garage
✨ Natural gas, municipal water, sewer and trash collection

Located in the Valley Central School District, with easy access to major highways, shopping, restaurants, parks, the Rail Trail and all that the Hudson Valley has to offer.

17 Princeton Drive | Walden, NY
3 Bedrooms | 2.5 Bathrooms | $447,000

📲 914-443-2246
📧 [email protected]
👩‍💻 Laurellustgarten.randrealty.com

08/06/2026

✨🏡 Some homes simply offer more - this is one of them.

Set on 6.1 beautiful acres, this exceptional home offers over 3,200 square feet of living space, an additional 900-square-foot finished basement and a flexible layout to suit your needs.

Sprawling floorplan, elegant formal spaces and family room with vaulted wood ceiling and stone fireplace create a warm and inviting interior. A first-floor primary suite adds convenience, while the upstairs offers flexibility and even a second primary suite.

Outside, enjoy an expansive wraparound deck overlooking peaceful, park-like grounds and the privacy that only acreage like this can provide.
Located in the Monroe-Woodbury School District with easy access to NYC transportation, highways and Hudson Valley attractions.

214 W. Mombasha Road, Monroe, NY
4 Bedrooms | 2.5 Bathrooms | $797,000

📲 914-443-2246
📧 [email protected]
👩‍💻 Laurellustgarten.randrealty.com

07/30/2026

✨🏡 Multiple offers. Over asking price. A 55% increase in value.

A beautiful colonial, lovingly maintained by its owner and thoughtfully presented to the market - buyers responded.

Originally purchased for $404,000 in 2020, it closed this week for $625,000 after attracting multiple offers and selling above the asking price.

That’s a $221,000 increase in value in just six years!

Every home and neighborhood is unique, but this sale is a reminder of how much values have changed. Even if a move isn’t on your radar, knowing what your home is worth is valuable information. When you’re ready for an honest assessment or simply have questions about the market, I’d love to be your real estate resource.

📲 914-443-2246
📧 [email protected]
👩‍💻 laurellustgarten.randrealty.com

07/20/2026

🌳🏡 It’s easy to fall in love with a home. It’s even easier to fall in love with a setting like this.

Nestled on two private acres in Circleville, this well-loved raised ranch offers nearly 2,000 square feet, peaceful wooded surroundings and the convenience of being just minutes from everything. A rare opportunity to enjoy space, privacy and a location that’s hard to beat.

33 Seaman Road, Circleville, NY
3 Bedrooms | 2.5 Bathrooms | $457,000

📲 914-443-2246
📧 [email protected]
👩‍💻 Laurellustgarten.randrealty.com

07/17/2026

Thank you for the feature!!

Address

229 Route 32
Central Valley, NY
10917

Telephone

+19144432246

Website

https://laurellustgarten.randrealty.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Laurel Lustgarten-Licensed Real Estate Salesperson posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Laurel Lustgarten-Licensed Real Estate Salesperson:

Want your business to be the top-listed Realtor/realty Service in Central Valley?