06/27/2026
Then & Now - 1976 to 2026
The story of the Worthington Inn began around 1835, when Rensselaer Cowles built a modest Federal-style home on High Street. By the 1850s, it had transformed into the Bishop House, an inn offering simple meals and lodging to travelers passing through central Ohio.
Through the late 1800s and early 1900s, the building evolved with each new owner, becoming the Central Hotel and later the Union Hotel. Additions expanded the space, including guest rooms, a grand staircase, and, after a 1901 fire, a third-floor ballroom that gave the structure its distinctive Victorian character. During this era, the Inn hosted everyone from local gatherings to traveling performers, university groups, and notable visitors.
In the early 20th century, the Depression and World War II took their toll on the building, which changed ownership and operators numerous time. However in 1952, George Snyder reopened the site as the āOld Worthington Inn,ā known for its beloved buffet and community-centered dining experience.
In 1983 with a major restoration led by new ownership. Historic materials were preserved and repurposed while expanding the property into a hotel, restaurant, and event space. For more than 30 years, it thrived as one of Worthingtonās most cherished destinations for celebrations and everyday dining. In 2007 the hotel rooms were converted into condominiums, and the restaurant closed in 2018.
After eight years, the first floor once again is home to a restaurant, with the opening of Wolf's Ridge at Worthington Inn!
In 1976, for the U.S. Bicentennial celebration, a series of photographs were taken around Worthington, including businesses and residences. Throughout 2026, this series will take a look at what has changed and what has stayed the same, as we celebrate America 250!