09/25/2026
Should the Owner Leave Paint, Extra Tile, Manuals and Spare Parts at the Rental?
Part 4 of the REALTOR® Resource Series
The home is cleaned. Repairs are finished. The tenant is almost ready to move in.
Then your landlord client points to a corner of the garage and asks:
“Should I leave all this stuff here for the tenant?”
There are half-used paint cans, a few pieces of matching tile, extra flooring, appliance manuals, air filters, hurricane supplies and miscellaneous parts collected over years of owning the home.
It may seem like a small decision.
But this is exactly the kind of detail that comes up when managing rental properties—and there isn't one answer for everything.
Some items can be extremely valuable to keep at the property.
Others are just clutter waiting to become somebody else's problem.
Here's how REALTORS® can help their landlord clients think through it.
1. Extra Paint Can Be Worth Keeping
Matching paint can be surprisingly useful.
If the owner knows exactly which paint was used throughout the property, keeping a properly sealed, clearly labeled amount can make future touch-ups much easier.
Ideally, document:
Paint brand
Color name
Color code
Finish or sheen
Room where it was used
But don't leave behind a collection of unidentified, rusting paint cans simply because they might be useful someday.
Useful and identifiable? Keep it appropriately.
Old, dried out and unknown? It's probably clutter.
2. Extra Flooring and Tile Can Be Extremely Valuable
This is one item owners often throw away too quickly.
If the home has a specific tile, laminate, vinyl plank or other flooring material, a few replacement pieces may become very valuable later.
Why?
Because the exact product may no longer be available when a repair is needed.
Replacing one damaged piece is much easier than discovering that the closest available match looks completely different.
If matching material is available, consider keeping a reasonable quantity in a designated storage area.
3. Appliance Manuals Are Helpful—But There May Be a Better Way
Owners often accumulate a drawer full of manuals.
Some are useful.
Some belong to appliances that haven't been in the property for ten years.
Before leaving them behind, determine which manuals actually correspond to equipment currently in the home.
Better yet, consider keeping digital copies or links to the manufacturer's instructions when available.
Useful documentation might include information for:
Refrigerator
Dishwasher
Washer and dryer
Range or oven
Thermostat
Water heater
Pool equipment
Garage door opener
The goal isn't to create a filing cabinet for the tenant.
It's to preserve useful information about the property.
4. Extra HVAC Filters Can Be Helpful
If the property requires an unusual filter size, leaving one or two clearly labeled replacement filters can be helpful.
More importantly, make sure everyone knows the correct filter size.
That information should be documented rather than relying on someone remembering it six months later.
For example:
AC Filter: 16 x 20 x 1
That's a tiny detail that can make routine property care much easier.
5. Garage Remotes, Gate Fobs and Keys Are Different
These aren't spare household items.
They're part of the property's access system.
Before move-in, account for exactly what exists:
Front-door keys
Side-door keys
Mailbox keys
Garage remotes
Gate remotes
Community fobs
Pool or amenity keys
Document what is being given to the tenant.
If the owner wants to retain a duplicate set for appropriate management or emergency purposes, that should be organized separately rather than leaving unidentified keys somewhere inside the home.
6. What About Hurricane Shutters and Hardware?
This is particularly important in South Florida.
If the property has removable hurricane shutters, panels, tracks, specialized hardware or installation tools, don't casually dispose of them during a cleanout.
They may be specific to that property.
The owner should know:
What hurricane protection belongs to the home
Where it is stored
Whether all necessary components are present
How the system is intended to be installed
A random bucket of bolts in the garage might look like junk—until a storm is approaching and someone discovers those were the shutter fasteners.
7. Don't Turn the Garage Into the Owner's Storage Unit
Here's where the line needs to be drawn.
A rental property should be delivered to the tenant as their home, not as storage space for everything the owner didn't want to move.
Avoid leaving behind unnecessary:
Furniture
Cleaning products
Old chemicals
Broken equipment
Scrap materials
Boxes
Personal belongings
Mystery hardware
Unless an item has a legitimate purpose for maintaining or operating the property, it generally shouldn't be taking up the tenant's usable space.
8. Decide Who Is Responsible for the Items Left Behind
This is the part people often forget.
Leaving something at the property can create another question:
Who is responsible for it?
For example, if an owner leaves a lawn mower, pressure washer, ladder or other equipment for the tenant's convenience, what happens when it breaks?
Was the item provided as part of the rental?
Is the owner expected to repair or replace it?
Was the tenant expected to maintain it?
Don't create unnecessary ambiguity.
If an item doesn't need to stay with the property, sometimes the simplest solution is not to leave it there.
REALTOR® Tip
When your landlord client asks whether something should stay, ask three questions:
Does it belong specifically to this property?
Could it reasonably help maintain, repair or operate the property later?
Will leaving it create confusion about who is responsible for it?
Those three questions will eliminate most of the guesswork.
The Bigger Lesson: Document the Property, Not Just the Lease
Experienced property managers don't rely on memory.
We document the little things.
Paint colors.
Filter sizes.
Garage remotes.
Gate fobs.
Shutter locations.
Appliance information.
Spare materials.
Vendor information.
Individually, these details seem insignificant.
But when a repair is needed two years from now, knowing exactly where the matching tile is stored—or what paint color was used in the hallway—can save the owner time, money and frustration.
That's property management: hundreds of small details handled correctly before they become bigger problems.
Property Management Minute for REALTORS®
You don't have to become a property manager just because your client decides to become a landlord.
The REALTOR® Resource Series from 1st Place Property Management is designed to answer the small, practical rental questions that don't always come up during traditional real estate transactions—but inevitably come up once a property becomes someone's home.
When one of those questions catches you off guard, we're here to be your property management resource.
You protect the client relationship.
We'll help you navigate the property management details.
1st Place Property Management
Your Property, Our Priority.