Andrew McElhinney Realtor

Andrew McElhinney Realtor Martha’s Vineyard native, who is eager to share his expertise with those looking to call the island their home.

Specializing in both Buyer and Seller representation.

SOLD | Congratulations to my buyers on this Lamberts Cove custom built home! 79 David Avenue | Martha’s VineyardSale Pri...
01/05/2026

SOLD | Congratulations to my buyers on this Lamberts Cove custom built home!

79 David Avenue | Martha’s Vineyard
Sale Price | $2,500,000
Buyer Representation | Andrew McElhinney
Seller Representation |

Please inquire about select buyer or seller representation.

JUST SOLD | Congratulations to my buyers on this home full of character and charm in the heart of Oak Bluffs! 9 Grovedal...
01/04/2026

JUST SOLD | Congratulations to my buyers on this home full of character and charm in the heart of Oak Bluffs!

9 Grovedale Rd | Martha’s Vineyard
Sale Price | $1,226,500
Buyer Representation | Andrew McElhinney
Seller Representation |

Please inquire about select buyer or seller representation.

NEWLY PRICED | Oak Bluffs Charmer – 3-bedroom, 2-bath home tucked away on a quiet road with Lagoon Pond access steps awa...
11/13/2025

NEWLY PRICED | Oak Bluffs Charmer – 3-bedroom, 2-bath home tucked away on a quiet road with Lagoon Pond access steps away.

9 Bayview Avenue | Martha’s Vineyard
List Price | $1,095,000
Listing Agent | Andrew McElhinney
COMPASS Exclusive

NEWLY LISTED | Edgartown Waterfront - Classic New England architecture meets the timeless allure of Martha’s Vineyard. T...
10/26/2025

NEWLY LISTED | Edgartown Waterfront - Classic New England architecture meets the timeless allure of Martha’s Vineyard. This exceptional waterfront estate is set on the edge of Sengekontacket Pond, offering a sandy shoreline, panoramic water views, and a private mooring.

9 Fowler Avenue | Edgartown
List Price | $5,250,000
Agent | Andrew McElhinney
Compass Exclusive Listing

Oak Bluffs Charmer – Welcome to 9 Bayview Avenue, a 3-bedroom, 2-bath home tucked away on a quiet road in Oak Bluffs wit...
10/04/2025

Oak Bluffs Charmer – Welcome to 9 Bayview Avenue, a 3-bedroom, 2-bath home tucked away on a quiet road in Oak Bluffs with Lagoon Pond access steps away.

9 Bayview Avenue | Martha’s Vineyard
List Price | $1,299,000
Listing Agent | Andrew McElhinney
COMPASS Exclusive

Designed by Outlands Design and built by McElhinney Construction, this home exemplifies modern coastal design. Spread ac...
09/24/2025

Designed by Outlands Design and built by McElhinney Construction, this home exemplifies modern coastal design. Spread across two thoughtfully designed levels, the interiors are bathed in natural light, highlighting the clean lines, open spaces, and high-end finishes throughout. The exterior is clad in timeless cedar shingles with crisp white trim, while expansive windows create a seamless indoor-outdoor connection.
*Agent is owner

34 Davis Street | Martha’s Vineyard
Listing Price | $2,395,000
Seller Representation | Andrew McElhinney
COMPASS Exclusive

JUST LISTED | 22 Sea Glen, a charming retreat nestled on a spacious lot offering future expansion. This home features 2 ...
07/13/2024

JUST LISTED | 22 Sea Glen, a charming retreat nestled on a spacious lot offering future expansion. This home features 2 bedrooms and 1.5 bathrooms spanning across 1,642 square feet of living space. Please reach out for a private showing.

22 Sea Glen Rd | Martha’s Vineyard
Listing Price | $1,100,000
Seller Representation | Andrew McElhinney
COMPASS Exclusive

Please inquire about select buyer or seller representation.

JUST SOLD | Congratulations to my client on their recent purchase of this rare 3.5 acre parcel. The purchase of this pro...
07/12/2024

JUST SOLD | Congratulations to my client on their recent purchase of this rare 3.5 acre parcel. The purchase of this property includes a stock holder membership to the highly coveted Farm Neck Golf Club.

Sale Price | $2,250,000
Buyer Representation | Andrew McElhinney
Seller Representation |

Please inquire about select buyer or seller representation.

Nestled in Vineyard Haven, 46 Red Buoy Lane is an exquisite and sophisticated home completed in 2022. This residence off...
05/21/2024

Nestled in Vineyard Haven, 46 Red Buoy Lane is an exquisite and sophisticated home completed in 2022. This residence offers 4 bedrooms and 3.5 bathrooms. The property’s unique offering of a one-bedroom apartment is noteworthy, providing an additional 597 sq ft.

46 Red Buoy Lane | Martha’s Vineyard
Price | $2,195,000
Seller Representation | Andrew McElhinney

Please inquire about select buyer or seller representation.

JUST SOLD | Congratulations to my buyer on this 3 bedroom ranch in close proximity to downtown Oak Bluffs and Farm Neck ...
05/16/2024

JUST SOLD | Congratulations to my buyer on this 3 bedroom ranch in close proximity to downtown Oak Bluffs and Farm Neck Golf Club.

12 Bellevue Ave | Martha’s Vineyard
Sale Price | $875,000
Buyer Representation | Andrew McElhinney

Please inquire about select buyer or seller representation.

Edgartown opportunity—Finish off the seller’s vision or create your own masterpiece! With over an acre of land, there is...
05/07/2024

Edgartown opportunity—Finish off the seller’s vision or create your own masterpiece! With over an acre of land, there is plenty of room to expand. Only two miles from lively downtown Edgartown, you get the privacy, beauty, and feel of the up-island without the commute.

4 Dubud Lane | Martha’s Vineyard
Sale Price | $1,599,000
Seller Representation | Andrew McElhinney

Please inquire about select buyer or seller representation.

Address

Edgartown, MA

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Andrew McElhinney Realtor posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Andrew McElhinney Realtor:

Shortcuts

Share

Category