Andrew McElhinney Realtor

Andrew McElhinney Realtor Martha’s Vineyard native, who is eager to share his expertise with those looking to call the island their home.

Specializing in both Buyer and Seller representation.

JUST LISTED | Offered fully furnished, this beautifully updated four-bedroom, two-bath home is a rare turnkey opportunit...
07/24/2026

JUST LISTED | Offered fully furnished, this beautifully updated four-bedroom, two-bath home is a rare turnkey opportunity in Oak Bluffs.

9 Chickawauke St | Oak Bluffs
Listing Price | $1,895,000
Seller Representation | Andrew McElhinney
Compass Exclusive

Please inquire about select buyer or seller representation.

07/10/2026

BIG BLUFF — A true architectural masterpiece. Perched above the Atlantic with panoramic ocean views.

Located within one of Edgartown’s most coveted waterfront enclaves, where properties are rarely offered, this exceptiona...
07/03/2026

Located within one of Edgartown’s most coveted waterfront enclaves, where properties are rarely offered, this exceptional 2.3-acre waterfront property encompasses over 240 feet of private sandy beach on Eel Pond.

91 Planting Field Way | Edgartown
$14,000,000
Compass Exclusive
Ralph Smth Jr.

Please inquire about select buyer or seller representation.

JUST SOLD | Such a pleasure representing the buyers & sellers for this one of a kind waterfront property! 10 Fowler Aven...
07/02/2026

JUST SOLD | Such a pleasure representing the buyers & sellers for this one of a kind waterfront property!

10 Fowler Avenue | Edgartown
Sale Price | $3,100,000
Buyer & Seller Representation | Andrew McElhinney
Compass Exclusive

Please inquire about select buyer or seller representation.

JUST SOLD | Edgartown Waterfront9 Fowler Avenue | Martha’s VineyardSale Price | $4,583,000Seller Representation | Andrew...
07/02/2026

JUST SOLD | Edgartown Waterfront

9 Fowler Avenue | Martha’s Vineyard
Sale Price | $4,583,000
Seller Representation | Andrew McElhinney Compass
Buyer Representation | Jennifer B. DaSilva

Please inquire about select buyer or seller representation.

BIG BLUFF | Set along the prestigious shoreline of East Chop, this estate represents a rare convergence of architectural...
05/12/2026

BIG BLUFF | Set along the prestigious shoreline of East Chop, this estate represents a rare convergence of architectural pedigree, craftsmanship, and irreplaceable setting. Link in bio.

150 E Chop Dr | Oak Bluffs, MA 02557
Listing Price | $8,900,000
Seller Representation | Andrew McElhinney
Exclusive

NEW LISTING | Big Bluff - An iconic coastal estate. This remarkable home has been recognized for its architectural signi...
05/08/2026

NEW LISTING | Big Bluff - An iconic coastal estate. This remarkable home has been recognized for its architectural significance and featured in leading design publications. With sweeping water views, timeless coastal design, and an unmatched setting, this property represents Vineyard living at its finest.

150 E Chop Drive | Oak Bluffs
Listing Price | $8,900,000
Seller Representation | Andrew McElhinney
Exclusive

JUST SOLD | A truly special project for myself & - Designed by .design and thoughtfully built with a focus on modern co...
05/07/2026

JUST SOLD | A truly special project for myself & -
Designed by .design and thoughtfully built with a focus on modern coastal living, this home blends timeless Vineyard character with clean, elevated interiors and exceptional craftsmanship throughout. Landscaping carefully curated by
*Agent is owner

Sale Price | $1,935,000
Seller Representation | Andrew McElhinney
Buyer Representation |
COMPASS Exclusive

SOLD | Congratulations to my buyers on this Lamberts Cove custom built home! 79 David Avenue | Martha’s VineyardSale Pri...
01/05/2026

SOLD | Congratulations to my buyers on this Lamberts Cove custom built home!

79 David Avenue | Martha’s Vineyard
Sale Price | $2,500,000
Buyer Representation | Andrew McElhinney
Seller Representation |

Please inquire about select buyer or seller representation.

Address

Edgartown, MA

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Andrew McElhinney Realtor posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Andrew McElhinney Realtor:

Shortcuts

Share

Category