08/07/2026
Continuing on my mission to try local spots around Nassau County to bring you local recommendations and information, we stopped by Breakable Hearts Bakery right here in Yulee yesterday! If you've been wanting to try the viral fruit pastries, cups of cake and other sweets this is a great local option without having to drive to Jacksonville.
They are located off 200, just past Walmart on the left (if you're headed towards the island). You turn on Blackrock road to park in their parking area, or if you're like me you miss the turn and have to do a u turn! The interior is beautiful, it has seating for about 4 at a table and a large bench for sitting as well. The staff was kind and helped recommend some items to me and my children.
We tried three of their "cups of cake" in double chocolate, red velvet, and lemon raspberry. My favorite by far was the lemon raspberry. It had layers of lemon curd and raspberry filling, and the bright, fresh flavors worked so well together. It was definitely the best dessert for me! My middle son picked this flavor, as we both love lemon, and it is his favorite as well out of our choices.
Yes, I have the whole family pitching in to help pick and choose what we review and share ā¤ļø
The chocolate and red velvet were good, but they had a much more subtle sweetness than I expected. Truly everything did, none of these items were super sweet in flavor. They reminded me a bit of dark chocolate or desserts made with less sugar. If you don't enjoy overly sweet treats, that may actually be something you'll love.
For the pastries, we tried the mango and the peach cobbler. The mango was good, but the peach cobbler peach pastry absolutely stole the show! It had an amazing peach filling paired with what tasted like a cobbler-style filling that really reminded me of peach cobbler. It was delicious!
Our favorites:
š„ Lemon Raspberry Cup of Cake
š„ Peach Cobbler Peach Pastry
As your local REALTORĀ®, I love sharing more than just homes. I want to be your go-to resource for great local restaurants, hidden gems, family activities, community events, and all the things happening around Yulee, Wildlight, Fernandina Beach, and Nassau County. If I find a spot worth trying, you'll hear about it here!