08/22/2026
🍷 Some dinners go far beyond the food, and Selby’s in Atherton was one of those evenings.
From the moment the front door was opened for us, the hospitality stood out. Bertane took amazing care of us, MJ spent time talking with us about the wine, and we even toured the cellar downstairs.
The 2021 The Mascot—better known at our table as “Baby Harlan”—was an excellent choice. Then the chef came out to visit us, making the evening feel even more personal. 🧑🍳
Of course, the food delivered too. The chocolate cake immediately reminded me of the kind Grandma used to make—great texture, comforting, and simply delicious. 🍰
Selby’s is certainly a special-occasion restaurant, but it never felt stuffy. We felt genuinely taken care of from beginning to end.
🌐 Find more local experiences at BayAreaWithPaul.com. If there’s somewhere you think I should visit next, go to Ask Paul on the website.