11/16/2026
What’s your opinion about this HOA request?? Let’s talk about it…
Wake Forest Woman Petitions HOA to Ban Neighbors From Cooking Collard Greens Inside Their Homes, Claims Smell Is Lowering Property Values
WAKE FOREST, NC — A New Jersey woman who recently purchased an $875,000 farmhouse-style home in Wake Forest is demanding her homeowners association prohibit residents from cooking collard greens after discovering she can smell them from inside her own house.
Jennifer Whitmore, 43, relocated from New Jersey earlier this year and says she was initially attracted to the neighborhood's Southern charm, tree-lined streets, and homes with names like The Magnolia and The Carolina Farmhouse.
What she wasn't expecting was actual Southern cooking.
"I paid almost $900,000 for this house. I shouldn't have to smell somebody's grandmother boiling vegetables every time I walk my Labradoodle"
Whitmore says the problem began last Sunday when her next-door neighbor, 76-year-old Mildred Hockaday, put a pot of collards on the stove around 8:30 a.m.
By 10:15, Whitmore claims the smell had traveled through the neighborhood and entered her home despite both houses having their windows closed.
"These people are cooking them INSIDE their houses, and somehow the smell is getting OUTSIDE and coming into MY house. How is that even legal?"
Whitmore has since submitted a 14-page complaint to her HOA demanding that collard greens be classified as an offensive residential odor, alongside cigarette smoke, sewage, and burning trash.
Her proposal would prohibit residents from cooking collards within 500 feet of another home and require anyone preparing them to install a commercial-grade ventilation system.
She also suggested residents consider alternatives such as kale, spinach, or prewashed spring mix.
"There's absolutely no reason a vegetable needs to cook for six hours. We have air fryers now."
"They smell like boiled gym socks and the New Jersey Turnpike"
Hockaday, who has been cooking collards in Wake County since 1968, says she has no intention of changing her Sunday routine.
"I put my ham hock in there about nine o'clock. If she don't like it, she can shut her nose."
The controversy intensified when Whitmore discovered several other residents were planning to cook collards for Thanksgiving.
She has requested an emergency HOA meeting before the holiday, arguing that simultaneous cooking could create what she described as a "neighborhood-wide atmospheric event."
"I moved here for the Southern lifestyle. The porches, the hospitality, the farmhouse architecture. Nobody mentioned the smell of boiled leaves."
The HOA reportedly declined to intervene after determining that cooking vegetables inside one's own home does not violate any existing neighborhood covenants.
Whitmore has since contacted a local real estate agent to determine whether the smell could affect her home's resale value.
The agent reportedly told her the neighborhood was extremely desirable, particularly because several residents still knew how to cook.
Whitmore says she is now considering moving to a newer development farther outside Wake Forest.
She has already identified a promising community called Collard Creek Preserve.