Cathy McDonald - Realtor

07/11/2026

I got to spend a few hours near Pymatuning State Park today looking at a potential camp listing less than a mile away! It’s been a long time since I’ve been here! Wow it is beautiful!

07/11/2026

Sold!!! 781 Sarsi Trail, Mercer pa

From Luxury Lake Front properties to Fixer uppers, I sell them all!
This fixer upper didn’t come without a few hurdles to overcome - it went under contract quickly, but due to some creative financing tactics, ended up taking some extreme effort and some extra time.
The good news is that we made it to closing with a couple of weeks in extensions!
Thank you to my seller Clarice for her patience and flexibility on getting this to the finish line!

Cathy McDonald
BHHS Home Services The Preferred Realty
Grove City, PA 16137
412-638-9540 (cell)
724-458-8800 (office)

07/03/2026

Just sold! Two beautiful lots on Sarsi Trail in Mercer, PA, in the beautiful Lake Latonka community! I was blessed to have represented both the seller and the buyer in this transaction! Congratulations and thank you to both! The lots are beautiful, and I can’t wait to see what their next chapter brings!!

06/29/2026

I have a client looking for a mobile home park or a multi unit apartment building.

If you have one you’re looking to sell, please DM me!

06/16/2026

🚨 PRIME COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE OPPORTUNITY in Seneca, PA! 🚨
Welcome to 3126 State Rte 257—an immaculate, highly versatile commercial property offering unbelievable value. 🏢✨ You simply could not build a facility of this caliber for this price point in today's market!
Currently operating as the beloved "Farmers Daughter," this exceptionally maintained ~5,900 sq. ft. building is ready for its next chapter. The best part? Most of the existing attached equipment is INCLUDED, making it a turnkey dream for your next venture! 🍳🚜
🌟 Property Highlights:
📍 Unbeatable Location: Prime frontage on two roads with outstanding visibility and high traffic counts. Just minutes from major national retailers like Walmart and McDonald's! 🚗💨
🍽️ Thoughtful Layout: Features a spacious seating area and a stunning loft perfectly suited for bridal showers, local events, or business gatherings. 🥂
🧑‍🍳 Fully Equipped: Boasts a professional chef's kitchen, walk-in cooler, dedicated loading/unloading area, and ample storage space. 🧊📦
💡 Endless Potential: This pristine space is ready to become a destination restaurant, large-scale retail outfitter, auto body shop, pro shop, bustling farmers market, commercial bakery, or dedicated event venue! 🎉
💰 Bonus Income Opportunity: There is enough space to easily sublease portions of the building if you want to partner with another business for additional revenue! 🤝
This is your opportunity to bring your vision to life and build your dream business!
🗝️ Ready to see it for yourself?
Send me a direct message, drop a comment below, Or call me!
Cathy McDonald
BHHS The Preferred Realty
501 W Main Street
Grove City, PA 16127
412-638-9540 (cell)
724-458-8800 (office)

06/14/2026

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️Offer accepted alert!!!⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

I spent the past several days with clients: new friends from Florida as their buyer’s agent and we found the one! Thank you to my past clients and friends- Zana and Joseph -for the referral! The referral means the world to me !!

I’m looking forward to working with the listing agent Jamie Peltenon from Realty One on this one! Thanks for also allowing me to use your photo!

This home is a beauty!!
Now let’s get through the process and take this one to the closing table!

Call me to find or sell your next home

Cathy McDonald
BHHS Grove City Pa
412-638-9540 (c)
7241458-8800 (o)

05/19/2026

🏡 NEW LISTING at Lake Latonka! 🌊✨

📍781 Sarsi Trail, Mercer, PA

Opportunity is knocking! 🔨💥 This spacious 4 bedroom, 3 bath home in the beautiful community of Lake Latonka is packed with potential and now includes the EXTRA adjacent LOT 1238 ! 🌳🙌

Whether you’re looking for a year-round residence, weekend getaway, or investment opportunity, this fixer upper offers the chance to create something truly special in one of the area’s most sought-after lake communities. 🛶☀️

✨ Features Include:
🛏️ 4 Bedrooms
🛁 3 Bathrooms
🌲 Additional Lot (1238) Included
🏠 Tons of Potential
🌊 Minutes from the lake & community amenities

Bring your vision and make this property your own! 💫

📲 Message me for details or to schedule your private showing!

PS: Thank you to Top Drone LLC for the awesome drone shot!

Cathy McDonald
BHHS Home Services The Preferred Realty
412-638-9540 (cell)
724-458-8800 (office)

Just Listed.781 Sarsi Trail, Mercer,Pa.

05/15/2026

JUST SOLD!!!
903 Ottawa Trail, Mercer, PA 16137

Congratulations to my buyers for purchasing 903 Ottawa Trail in the beautiful community of Lake Latonka! This special home came with a nice-sized lot and has a sneak peek of the lake!
Shout out to Dave Hall for being the listing agent and to Adam Slade and team at US Mortgage Network for their closing services.
And a special thank you to my manager Renee Porterfield for her help throughout the sale.

I still have a lot of buyers waiting for the right home! Give me a call if you're looking to buy or ready to sell!

Cathy McDonald
Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices The Preferred Realty
Office 724-458-8800
Cell 412-638-9540

Just Sold!.903 Ottawa Trail.

04/07/2026

Another lake front property sold! Congratulations to my buyers/ new friends and neighbors Keith and Peggy! Wishing you many years of fun and happiness in your new home!

03/25/2026

🎉 ACCEPTED OFFER!! 🎉

Another beautiful Lake Latonka residence is officially contingent! 🏡💙

I had the pleasure of bringing the buyer—and yes… this one comes with some pretty nice lake views 🌅✨

So excited for what’s ahead for my clients! 🥂

Looking forward to a smooth process and closing!

📸 Photo courtesy of listing agent David Hall

Cathy McDonald
BHHS Grove City Pa
412-638-9540 Cathy’s cell
724-458-8800 office