Susan Martello, Realtor-Broker, J.D

Susan Martello, Realtor-Broker, J.D ✨Lawyer Gone Indy Realtor🏡 Susan is a former attorney turned real estate agent in Indianapolis and surrounding suburbs. But it can also be stressful.

In 2022, PropertySpark ranked Susan among the TOP 20 INDIANAPOLIS REALTORS on social media, effectively marketing each of her clients’ homes on multiple social media platforms. Susan loves serving her clients and helping them enter the next chapter in life whatever that maybe. “It’s a very exciting time when you’re buying or selling a home. It’s a new beginning where anything seems possible! I’m r

ight by your side guiding and advising you every step of the way. My goal is to make the home buying and selling process the best experience you’ve ever had.” Whether selling a million-dollar home or representing a first-time homebuyer, Susan strives to provide her clients with friendly personalized service, exceptional marketing skills, and local market expertise. Prior to her real estate career, Susan practiced law for almost a decade and served as a judicial law clerk to the Indiana Supreme Court. Searching for a more balanced and purposeful life, she decided to leave the law to follow her passion for real estate and never looked back. Susan’s legal experience has helped tremendously over the course of her eight-year real estate career. Her legal background allows her to effectively negotiate purchase price and terms, advocate for her clients, and properly navigate through any transaction. Susan is a native Hoosier currently residing in Zionsville with her husband Scott and their rescue pup, Henry. She was also a professional photographer with a focus on portrait and family photography and enjoys gardening, working out, travel, wine, and cooking.

🇪🇸 From Barcelona to Indy! 🇺🇸 Congratulations to my clients on going under contract on their first home in the U.S.! 🎉🔑 ...
06/17/2026

🇪🇸 From Barcelona to Indy! 🇺🇸 Congratulations to my clients on going under contract on their first home in the U.S.! 🎉🔑

This is the third home I've sold in Bates-Hendricks (one was an Airbnb!) 🏠 While I love the Fountain Square vibe, you'll often get more bang for your buck in BH while still being close to everything the city has to offer. 💰✨

🤔 Is it your turn to invest in your future? You know who to call! Susan Martello, your Lawyer-Gone-Indy Realtor® 📞 (317) 507-2004


-Hendricks , , , , ,

🏡✨ Pending on a new build in Zionsville! ✨🏡 So excited for my clients as they officially go under contract on their futu...
05/25/2026

🏡✨ Pending on a new build in Zionsville! ✨🏡 So excited for my clients as they officially go under contract on their future home! There’s something special about building a home that’s designed specifically for you from the ground up — and I can’t wait to see it all come together for them!

�⭐️Thinking about building your dream home too? Let’s find the perfect lot and get started! 🏠 Call TODAY!

📲Susan Martello, Lawyer-Gone-IndyRealtor, (317) 507-2004

💫Special thanks to fellow eXp rockstar, Cathy Richardson for helping get this beauty under contract whilst I was away on vacation!

, ,

Most buyers are checking Zillow every day… 👀…and still losing. ❌ Because by the time a home hits Zillow—it can already t...
04/16/2026

Most buyers are checking Zillow every day… 👀
…and still losing. ❌

Because by the time a home hits Zillow—
it can already too late. ⏰

That’s why my clients don’t play that game. 💁🏻‍♀️
Instead, we:
✨ Got in before it hit the market
🚫 Avoided the bidding war
⏳ Negotiated a 60-day close to sell their home first at full asking price
💰 Got the seller to buy down their rate

No competition. No chaos. Just strategy. 🧠

📲Susan Martello, Lawyer-Gone-IndyRealtor, (317) 507-2004

Comment “OFF MARKET” and I’ll send you our team’s 2026 Buyer Guide 📘

offmarkethomes homebuying realestatetips indyluxury househunting realestateexpert indianapolishomes

04/13/2026

🎉 Our Team had this Beauty Under Contract in just 1 DAY! 🎉 Multiple offers. Strong demand. Unrivaled marketing and expertise that deliver. 🌷 The spring market is HERE—and buyers are out in full force 🏡

👉🏻The question is… are you ready to list? NOW is the time. Call/DM Susan, Lawyer-Gone-Indy Realtor, 317.507.2004

📍 6569 Hunters Ridge, Zionsville

, , ,

03/19/2026

‼️ATTENTION HOMEOWNERS‼️You might not have to sell first before you buy a new home! Watch this Video to find out why! 👀 👉Call/Text Susan at (317) 507-2004 for a quick and easy seller consult!🏡

IG: -Gone-IndyRealtor 💚

, , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

03/07/2026

I’ve never been a baker but it’s growing on me! 🍌👩‍🍳 I’m trying to perfect my healthy banana bread…still needs work. 😆 What’s your favorite thing to do on a rainy Saturday? 🌧️

03/02/2026

🔥 UNDER CONTRACT in just 4 days! 🔥

🥳 991 N. Bolton Ave. is officially off the market—and FAST! Strategic pricing and timing + turnkey home = selling quickly for top dollar!💰

🌸 The SPRING MARKET is here and rates are below 6% so serious buyers are out in full force. If you’ve been thinking about selling, NOW is the time!

👉Who you hire matters! Call/Text Susan at (317) 507-2004 for a free and easy seller consult. Trust your Lawyer-Gone-IndyRealtor®!

, indianapolis, irvington, homesforsalenearme, topindyrealtor, bestindyrealtor

02/07/2026

🥳 THREE OFFERS ACCEPTED IN ONE WEEK!🥳 To hear my clients’ excitement when I  say “You got the house!” means the world! 🥹 Cheers to THREE amazing families who got their offers accepted this week! 🏡 You did it!! 🥂

📍 7600 N. Meridian, Indianapolis — Off-Market Deal
📍 6678 West 14th St., Indianapolis —  Winning Bid Over A First Right Contingency Offer
📍 3418 Carr Ave., Indianapolis — Winning Bid Against Multiple Offers

📞 Call or DM Susan, your Lawyer.Gone.Indy Realtor, 317.507.2004 TODAY to get you in a new home by Spring! 🌸

, , ,
carmelrealtor, IndianapolisRealEstate HomeSweetHome
BuyingInIndy homesforsalenearme, realestatebroker, topzionsvillebroker, topindybroker, topindyrealtor, relocationexpert, relocatingtoindy, relocatingtoindy

01/31/2026

🥳 THREE OFFERS ACCEPTED IN ONE WEEK!🥳 To hear my clients’ excitement and relief when I say “You got the house!” over the phone —that feeling never gets old. 🥹 I’m incredibly grateful to be able to experience the joy along with them and help them step into their next stage in life. Cheers to THREE amazing families who got their offers accepted this week! 🏡 You did it!! 🥂

📍 6678 West 14th St., Indianapolis — First Right Contingency
📍 7600 N. Meridian, Indianapolis — Off-Market Deal
📍 3418 Carr Ave., Indianapolis — Won Against Multiple Offers

📞 Call or DM Susan, your lawyer-gone-Indy Realtor, 317.507.2004 TODAY!

, , , ,
, , , , , , ,

12/29/2025

🏡🍃 How the Seasons Shape the Real Estate Market 🍂❄️ Christmas maybe over but I’m still in that holiday mode! If you’re curious about when’s the BEST time to list or buy, here’s my gift to you….
 
🌸 Spring – The busiest season of all! More buyers, more competition, and typically the best
time to sell for top dollar.
☀️ Summer – Strong momentum continues with serious buyers and smooth moves, especially for families.
🍁 Fall – Fewer buyers means less competition, making it a great window for savvy shoppers.
❄️ Winter – Think winter as being the Cyber Season of Real Estate for buyers 💻 Hello deals! 👀💰
 
📞 Call Susan, 317-507-2004 — your lawyer-gone-Indy realtor — and let’s time your move just
right! 
 
,

Address

Indianapolis, IN

Website

,

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Susan Martello, Realtor-Broker, J.D posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Susan Martello, Realtor-Broker, J.D:

Shortcuts

Share

Category