Natalie Clayton, Founder & Broker, Maywright Property Co.

Home
United States
Indianapolis, IN
Natalie Clayton, Founder & Broker, Maywright Property Co.

Maywright believes exceptional clients deserve an excepional brokerage. Whistler Award.

Top 1% Realtor in Indianapolis
Natalie is a founder and broker of Maywright Property Co., a fully-woman-owned real estate firm serving clients and neighborhoods in central Indiana. As one of the top-ranked agents in Indianapolis, with over $20M in sales in 2020 and having led a team of agents that topped $60M in the same year, she brings to her work expertise, compassion and a commitment to empowe

ring her clients and brokers every step of the way. In addition to her work at Maywright, Natalie owns 10+ real estate investments that range from single-family, multi-family and short-term rental. She believes in small business and is an investor in Milktooth, a nationally recognized restaurant in the Fletcher Place neighborhood. With more than 1,500 hours of service, Natalie founded Bourbon Women Indy, serves as vice president of the board at the Athenaeum Foundation, is president of the Community Heights Neighborhood Association, and is a member of Impact 100. In 2016, Natalie and her husband also launched a scholarship program for students who have shown a commitment to community and public service. Natalie is an Indianapolis native, a graduate of IUPUI, and has dedicated her career to knowing and serving this city and its people. Prior to entering real estate in 2017, Natalie spent a decade working in government and nonprofits, including serving as deputy director of the Greater Indianapolis Progress Committee under Mayor Ballard where she worked on projects like Eskenazi Hospital, Bank on Indy and the Charles L. She has also held roles at the National Future Farmers of America and the Indiana State Museum. Since launching her real estate career, Natalie has been recognized as Rookie of the Year, an alumna of MIBOR's Real Estate Academy of Leadership (Class of 2018-2019), and the Bud Tucker Scholarship recipient. Natalie and her husband, Indiana State Representative Blake Johnson, reside in Indianapolis with their two dogs, Jack and Jamison.

06/18/2026

A good realtor will help you buy a house. A great one will make sure it's actually the right one.

When you're new to buying or selling, it's easy to assume every agent is basically doing the same job. They show you homes, write offers, hand over keys. But the way an agent actually does that job is what separates a smooth move from a stressful one you're still telling stories about years later.

The best ones treat your move like it's their own. They take the time to understand the way you actually live, they slow you down when you need to be slowed down, and they're still around long after the boxes are unpacked.

If you're starting to think about a move and want someone who'll be in your corner the whole way through, I'd love to chat.

Reach out to Natalie today for your real estate needs: 317-522-8727 | [email protected]

06/16/2026

Sold | Cottage Home

My sellers spent the time to get their home feeling better than new, and it paid off! This custom, Stenz built property offered the best of all things - location, newer construction and special touches like one-of-a-kind trim and finishes. Congrats to all!

Reach out to Natalie today for your real estate needs: 317-522-8727 | [email protected]

06/13/2026

Just listed | Carmel

1578 Charity Chase Dr
5 bd | 3.5 ba | 4,430 sqft
Offered at $675,000
More info: https://bit.ly/4vI2d5q

Welcome to Carmel's Desirable Saddle Creek Neighborhood - Complete with Pool, Tennis Basketball, and Walking Trails | This stunning, brick home on Charity Chase boasts the largest floor plan, complete with 5 bedrooms, 3.5 bathrooms, a main floor office, a light-soaked sunroom, finished basement (including a bedroom and full bathroom) and side-load 3-car garage. You're going to love the refinished hardwood floors, dual story living room with gas fireplace and backyard, complete with ample trees and newer black aluminum fencing. Upstairs, the primary bedroom offers a retreat behind french doors and features a vaulted ceiling, an en suite bath with soaking tub and full shower and walk-in closet. Three additional bedrooms and another full bath round out the upper floor. Mechanicals: Furnace & AC (2024) Water Heater (2023) Roof & 6" Gutters (2021) 2nd Floor, Garage, Laundry Windows (2021). What Stays: Double Oven, Gas Range, Refrigerator, Dishwasher, Microwave & Vent Hood (to exterior), Washer, Dryer, Security System and Ring Doorbell, Water Softener, RO System, Sump With Battery Backup and Sprinkler System.

Reach out to Natalie today for your real estate needs: 317-522-8727 | [email protected]

06/11/2026

Summer in Indy is great, but sometimes you just need a change of scenery.
Luckily, you don't have to go far. 🚗☀

Some of the best weekend trips are within driving distance. Plus this list has something for every one!

Reach out to Natalie today for your real estate needs: 317-522-8727 | [email protected]

06/09/2026

Sold | Near Bates-Hendricks

My buyer is thrilled to have found this home that checks all their boxes - from tons of natural light, to a backyard for gardening, to access to the Pleasant Run Trail across the street. Congrats!

Reach out to Natalie today for your real estate needs: 317-522-8727 | [email protected]

Listing photo c/o Hoosier, REALTORS®

06/07/2026

Listed exclusively by Natalie Clayton, Maywright | Mapleton-Fall Creek
OPEN TODAY 1-2p

3699 N Delaware St
3 bd | 2.5 ba | 3,805 sqft
Offered at $525,000
More info: https://bit.ly/4vx0IHd

One-Of-A-Kind All-Brick Historic Home Featuring German Revival Architecture, A Newer 100-Year Slate Roof And Located On The Most Breathtaking Block In Indianapolis - Meridian Kessler-Adjacent | 3 bed, 2.5 baths & 3,800+ total sqft | This is your chance to be the 4th owner of this incredible home that boasts original hardwood floors, original 1920s tile, tons of leaded glass and stained glass windows, original lighting, 10-foot ceilings and more. The main floor lives like a dream, from the oversized living room, with fireplace, dual french doors and sunroom, to the dining room that opens via french doors to a quaint patio for morning coffee and evening sips, to the expansive and newly renovated kitchen, complete with an induction down-draft stove, high end refrigerator and quartz countertops. Upstairs, take note of the European-imported carpet, tightly woven for a forever-wear (hardwoods under carpeting upstairs). The primary bedroom has been built for today's modern conveniences including an en suite bath, with a soaking tub shower and walk-in closet. The second full bath is spacious, and don't miss a true stairway to the unfinished attic - an opportunity to add even more space and value. The basement offers ample storage, tall ceilings and more opportunity to make the home your own. Don't miss the new sewer line, too. Outside, enjoy the extensive landscaping investment already made across a fully fenced property, including secret-garden-esque yard just off the oversized, covered patio. Lastly, the concrete driveway and two-car garage round out this rare opportunity. Ask to see the full list of investments. P.S. This one was featured on the Mid-North Holiday Home Tour!

Reach out to Natalie today for your real estate needs: 317-522-8727 | [email protected]

06/04/2026

Sold | Fall Creek Place

My seller spent nearly two decades curating this home and making meaningful investments. Now, the buyer can enjoy this elevated condo nestled in the coziest setting in desired Fall Creek Place. Congrats to everyone involved!

Reach out to Natalie today for your real estate needs: 317-522-8727 | [email protected]

06/02/2026

Hello heat and humidity. June is all about keeping air flowing and moisture under control—check out what to tackle on this month’s home checklist.

Reach out to Natalie today for your real estate needs: 317-522-8727 | [email protected]

05/29/2026

Long sunny evenings, local festivals, and Pride Month celebrations make June a great time to get out and enjoy the Indy community!

Address

1220 Waterway Boulevard
Indianapolis, IN
46202

Website

http://natalieatmaywright.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Natalie Clayton, Founder & Broker, Maywright Property Co. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Natalie Clayton, Founder & Broker, Maywright Property Co.:

Shortcuts

Want your business to be the top-listed Realtor/realty Service in Indianapolis?