06/17/2026
Tucked into a quiet harbor on Lower Matecumbe, this Islamorada address feels like a hidden pocket of the Keys.
First time on the market, Fantasy Harbor offers protected dockage, a 99' concrete seawall, boat lift, open living areas, and a covered party hut made for long afternoons outside.
76412 Overseas Highway
3 bed • 3 bath • 2,000 sf
Offered at $2.3M
DM us for for full details.