Tabitha Casto Real Estate Broker

10/19/2026

SOLD | 712/714 S 5TH ST., LAFAYETTE, IN

Congratulations to my seller on another successful closing of a multi-unit property in her portfolio! We’re happy to see this property transfer to another locally and privately owned landlord.

To my dearest client- thank you for continuing to trust me with the growth and expansion of your rental portfolio. Your repeat business is the greatest compliment I could receive, and I’m grateful to be part of your continued success!

Cheers to all parties involved and to another successful closing!

10/18/2026

PRICE IMPROVEMENT | SOUTH SIDE HOME ON A BASEMENT

1221 Brick N Wood Drive, Lafayette, IN
Now Offered at $406,900.00

Welcome to 1221 N Brick N Wood, a beautifully maintained two-story home with a fully finished basement, tucked away on a quiet cul-de-sac in a mature south-side neighborhood. Centrally located near dining, shopping, schools, walking trails, US 52, US 231, and just a short commute to Purdue University, this home offers both comfort and convenience. Step inside to a spacious great room filled with natural light and featuring a cozy fireplace, beautiful views of the backyard, and a formal dining area. The entire main level has been freshly painted, with custom-sized curtains added. The updated kitchen features solid-surface countertops, a newly installed water filtration system, a new oven/range converted to gas, and a large updated pantry with extra storage. The main-level primary suite offers a private retreat with its own full bathroom and a new glass sliding door providing direct access to the landscaped backyard. A convenient half bath is located just off the foyer on the first floor. Upstairs, you’ll find two spacious bedrooms, a third bedroom currently being used as an office, and an additional full bathroom. The fully finished basement adds even more living and workspace, featuring a large second great room, an additional office, laundry room, updated windows, and a newly added bathroom. The sellers have also installed a whole-home humidifier and new water softener. Step outside to your own backyard oasis. The fully fenced yard offers privacy, mature landscaping, planted trees, flowers, and a spacious patio complete with a recently installed gazebo—perfect for relaxing or entertaining. Lovingly maintained by its current owners, this home has seen numerous thoughtful updates throughout their ownership. Come see everything 1221 N Brick N Wood has to offer and schedule your private tour today!

10/06/2026

OPEN HOUSE | SOUTH SIDE HOME ON A BASEMENT

1221 Brick N Wood Drive, Lafayette, IN 47909
Sunday, October 11th, 2026
From 1:00PM-3:00PM

Come see me and tour this two story home nestled on a cul-de-sac on the south side of Lafayette! Seller has made lots of updates like finishing the basement, adding a half bath, fully fencing backyard, new windows lower level, new appliances, installing gazebo, painting, flooring, landscaping and so much more. See you there!

10/06/2026

PRICE IMPROVEMENT | DOWNTOWN CONDO

12 N 3rd St., #302, Lafayette, IN 47901
Now Offered at $385,000.00

Great opportunity to own a condo in the Historic Earl and Hatcher building, a 1865 landmark originally built for Earl and Hatcher Wholesale Grocers that was thoughtfully converted into charming, modern residences in 2013. This impeccably maintained unit sits on N 3rd Street, just one block from the picturesque Tippecanoe courthouse and within easy walking distance of coffee shops, pubs, fine dining, the Wabash Heritage Pedestrian Bridge to campus, local shops, and downtown Main Street festivals. Inside, you’ll find a beautifully updated kitchen with solid-surface countertops and stainless-steel appliances, flowing into an enlarged dining area. The living space showcases a stunning brick wall and large windows that flood the room with natural light and offer downtown views. The primary bedroom is generous in size, featuring a luxurious bathroom with a soaker tub, separate shower, twin vanities, and ample closet space. A powder room, a spacious coat closet, and a laundry area add everyday convenience. Thoughtful details include hardwood floors, detailed molding, exposed brick, and tasteful finishes throughout. There are three access points to the unit: from the parking garage, from Third Street, and from the alley, with elevator access plus stairs. Parking is available through a third-party provider. The HOA covers water and trash, and the unit is fully electric. This turn-key condo combines historic charm with modern comfort in a walkable, coveted neighborhood. Don’t miss your chance to own in this iconic building and enjoy all that downtown living has to offer.

10/06/2026

PRICE IMPROVEMENT | HISTORIC DOWNTOWN HOME

1311 Columbia Street, Lafayette, IN 47901
Now Offered at $445,000.00

This is a rare opportunity to own a historic home in the heart of Downtown Lafayette! The Wagner-Shambaugh House was built in 1913 for sisters Laura, Philomena, and Lucille Wagner, who had previously lived with their father, John Wagner, on North 4th Street. A German immigrant and prominent b**r baron, John Wagner was associated with the famed Thieme & Wagner Brewing Company. The house reflects a mixture of Colonial Revival and Classical Revival styles, befitting the prominence of the Wagner family at the time. In 1925, Gertrude Shambaugh purchased the home and lived there until 1981. A pioneering businesswoman, Shambaugh was one of the first women in the country to own and operate her own automobile dealerships. Her long association with the house became an important part of its history. The home also retains a special connection to the Wagner family's earlier residence at 715 N. 4th Street, built in the 1850s. The Baroque Revival chandeliers in the living room and dining room were brought to the 1913 house by the Wagner sisters from their original home, preserving a tangible piece of the family's earlier history within their new residence. After decades of history and changing ownership, the Wagner-Shambaugh House was brought back to life by the Robinson family in the late 20th century. Their efforts helped preserve the home's architectural character and the stories of the families who shaped its history, allowing the Wagner-Shambaugh House to remain a lasting reminder of Lafayette's architectural and cultural heritage. Schedule a tour today to view this amazing property on a large lot within walking distance to Historic Main Street! Contact listing agent for more information about property details.

10/03/2026

JUST LISTED | DOWNTOWN NEW BUILD

603 S 3rd Street, Lafayette, IN
Offered at $307,000.00

Experience the joy of new construction in this stunning home, now complete and ready for you to make lasting memories! The open main level floorplan is perfect for entertaining, featuring a delightful kitchen with solid surface countertops, stainless steel appliances, a center island, and a spacious walk-in pantry. The expansive great room, dining area, and inviting entryway with a ventless fireplace provide a flexible living space for your needs. Retreat to the second floor where all three bedrooms await, ensuring comfort and privacy away from the main living area. Each home showcases distinct architecture and vibrant exterior colors, creating a unique sense of community. Embrace 21st-century living in the charming and peaceful historic Ellsworth Romig neighborhood, just minutes from downtown. Enjoy leisurely walks or bike rides to your favorite locally owned restaurants, parks, downtown Farmer's Market, Main Street festivals and all things historic Lafayette! Relish the convenience of having Miller Elementary just a block away for your kids. This home offers the perfect blend of modern living in a historic setting. Truly a unique place to call your own! HOA includes lawn car and snow removal and is $75/mo.

10/01/2026

OPEN HOUSE | HISTORIC DOWNTOWN HOME

1311 Columbia Street, Lafayette, IN 47901
Sunday, October 4th
1:00PM- 3:00PM

Come tour this property and learn what it's like to own a piece of old city history! Link to full property details in the comments.

This is a rare opportunity to own a historic home in the heart of Downtown Lafayette! The Wagner-Shambaugh House was built in 1913 for sisters Laura, Philomena, and Lucille Wagner, who had previously lived with their father, John Wagner, on North 4th Street. A German immigrant and prominent b**r baron, John Wagner was associated with the famed Thieme & Wagner Brewing Company. The house reflects a mixture of Colonial Revival and Classical Revival styles, befitting the prominence of the Wagner family at the time. In 1925, Gertrude Shambaugh purchased the home and lived there until 1981. A pioneering businesswoman, Shambaugh was one of the first women in the country to own and operate her own automobile dealerships. Her long association with the house became an important part of its history. The home also retains a special connection to the Wagner family's earlier residence at 715 N. 4th Street, built in the 1850s. The Baroque Revival chandeliers in the living room and dining room were brought to the 1913 house by the Wagner sisters from their original home, preserving a tangible piece of the family's earlier history within their new residence. After decades of history and changing ownership, the Wagner-Shambaugh House was brought back to life by the Robinson family in the late 20th century. Their efforts helped preserve the home's architectural character and the stories of the families who shaped its history, allowing the Wagner-Shambaugh House to remain a lasting reminder of Lafayette's architectural and cultural heritage. Schedule a tour today to view this amazing property on a large lot within walking distance to Historic Main Street! Contact listing agent for more information about property details.

09/29/2026

In case you missed it- Check out the link to one of my newest listings! This breathtaking Edwardian Era home sits in the heart of Brookston and is in stunning condition. Meticulously maintained and just a short commute to West Lafayette/Purdue University. Reach out for more details or to schedule a private showing!

Listed at $495,000, MLS #202638164, 4 beds, 1 bath, 2-car garage, 2,842 square feet, built in 1907, Step back in time to 1907 and experience the timeless beauty of a true Victorian treasure! Rarely does a home come along that allows you to experience history while still offering the space and functi...

09/29/2026

NEW ON MARKET | SOUTH SIDE HOME ON A BASEMENT

1221 Brick N Wood, Lafayette, IN 47905
Offered at $415,000.00

Welcome to 1221 N Brick N Wood, a beautifully maintained two-story home with a fully finished basement, tucked away on a quiet cul-de-sac in a mature south-side neighborhood. Centrally located near dining, shopping, schools, walking trails, US 52, US 231, and just a short commute to Purdue University, this home offers both comfort and convenience. Step inside to a spacious great room filled with natural light and featuring a cozy fireplace, beautiful views of the backyard, and a formal dining area. The entire main level has been freshly painted, with custom-sized curtains added. The updated kitchen features solid-surface countertops, a newly installed water filtration system, a new oven/range converted to gas, and a large updated pantry with extra storage. The main-level primary suite offers a private retreat with its own full bathroom and a new glass sliding door providing direct access to the landscaped backyard. A convenient half bath is located just off the foyer on the first floor. Upstairs, you’ll find two spacious bedrooms, a third bedroom currently being used as an office, and an additional full bathroom. The fully finished basement adds even more living and workspace, featuring a large second great room, an additional office, laundry room, updated windows, and a newly added bathroom. The sellers have also installed a whole-home humidifier and new water softener. Step outside to your own backyard oasis. The fully fenced yard offers privacy, mature landscaping, planted trees, flowers, and a spacious patio complete with a recently installed gazebo—perfect for relaxing or entertaining. Lovingly maintained by its current owners, this home has seen numerous thoughtful updates throughout their ownership. Come see everything 1221 N Brick N Wood has to offer and schedule your private tour today!

09/29/2026

Check out the link to my newest listing! This property sits at the end of a quiet cut-de-sac, in a mature neighborhood, on the south side of Lafayette!