Tabitha Casto Real Estate Broker

Tabitha Casto Real Estate Broker A specialized REALTOR dedicated to the Greater Lafayette region since 2012. By your side from day one, to the closing table and beyond!

With areas of expertise in the downtown Lafayette area, particularly in historic homes, preservation, real estate development and investment portfolios. My goal is to connect buyers and sellers together with exceptional customer satisfaction.

SOLD | 1505 ADAMS STREET, LAFAYETTE, INA big shoutout to both my seller and buyer on closing the deal for this charming,...
05/22/2026

SOLD | 1505 ADAMS STREET, LAFAYETTE, IN

A big shoutout to both my seller and buyer on closing the deal for this charming, cozy cottage! I'm so grateful to my buyer for coming back to work with me again, and a huge thank you to my seller for putting your trust in me to sell your home. Here’s to everyone involved in this wonderful journey!

Considering buying or selling? Lets chat! (765) 427-2501

NEW ON MARKET | COZY RANCH1744 N 13th, Lafayette, IN 47904Offered at $165,000.00 Welcome to this charming ranch nestled ...
05/19/2026

NEW ON MARKET | COZY RANCH

1744 N 13th, Lafayette, IN 47904
Offered at $165,000.00

Welcome to this charming ranch nestled at the end of a peaceful street! The seller has taken great care of this home, making numerous updates along the way. As you step inside, you'll notice fresh paint throughout and a beautifully remodeled kitchen featuring a spacious island, stainless steel appliances, and a lovely tile backsplash. There are two cozy bedrooms and a bathroom tucked away at the back of the house. When you head out the back door, you'll be greeted by a brand new deck that's perfect for unwinding while enjoying views of the expansive backyard. Plus, there’s a full privacy fence for added comfort. At the end of the yard, you'll discover a large detached garage offering plenty of storage and extra space for you to get creative. Schedule a private tour today!

05/19/2026

Listed at $165,000, MLS #202618965, 2 beds, 1 bath, 1-car garage, 672 square feet, built in 1946, 0.1316, Welcome to this charming ranch nestled at the end of a peaceful street! The seller has taken great care of this home, making numerous updates along the way. As you step inside, you'll notice fre...

INVESTOR OPPORTUNITY | PACKAGE DEALI have a unique opportunity for any investor looking to expand their portfolio by acq...
05/13/2026

INVESTOR OPPORTUNITY | PACKAGE DEAL

I have a unique opportunity for any investor looking to expand their portfolio by acquiring 4 doors in one transaction. This package deal includes a triplex and single family home, both located within the downtown area. Seller is requiring these be sold together, as they intend to 1031 exchange both funds into one singular property. Here are the details below;

712/714 S 5TH STREET, LAFAYETTE, IN
OFFERED AT $219,900.00
This is a large triplex, fully rented and offering spacious units. Two units are located on the main floor, with one unit on the second floor. Seller includes all utilities in rent. Currently grossing $2,765 per month, with gross rent increasing to $2,870 per month on 6/1. Prime location sitting at the edge of Highland Park, nestled just steps away from the top of 4th street hill. Tenants can easily walk down the hill and hit historic downtown within minutes. Short commute to Purdue on bike, bus, or vehicle. Large backyard space for tenants to enjoy as well.

1029 N 6TH STREET, LAFAYETTE, IN
OFFERED AT $154,000.00
This is a single family home one block from The 6th Street Dive, local laundry mat, bus route and short commute across the bridge to Purdue campus. Seller is installing a brand new roof on 5/14. This property is currently being rented for $1,075/per month with ample opportunity for rent increase in future- if new owner desires. This home has 2 bedrooms, with 2 full baths. Original hardwood floors and details, large fenced in backyard, parking in the rear, basement, den, formal dining room and additional flex space upstairs. Tenant pays all utilities.

Please don't hesitate to reach out to for more details. (765) 427-2501. Zillow links in the comments below.

SOLD | 3017 FAIRWOOD DRIVE, LAFAYETTE, INI’m absolutely thrilled about this closing because I had the chance to work wit...
05/08/2026

SOLD | 3017 FAIRWOOD DRIVE, LAFAYETTE, IN

I’m absolutely thrilled about this closing because I had the chance to work with my best friend! A few years back, I helped Lisa buy her first home, and after turning it into an investment property for the past four years, we’re now passing it on to a first-time homebuyer who will make it their primary residence, just like Lisa did at the beginning. It’s such a charming little house, and we’ve created countless memories in that backyard. Congratulations, my friend! I adore you so much! 💕

Everyone enjoy the second slide of a much younger, more innocent version of your favorite dynamic duo...

NEW ON MARKET | RANCH NEAR THE PARK710 S 27th Street, Lafayette, IN 47904Offered at $175,000.00Here’s a fantastic chance...
05/05/2026

NEW ON MARKET | RANCH NEAR THE PARK

710 S 27th Street, Lafayette, IN 47904
Offered at $175,000.00

Here’s a fantastic chance to own a charming 2-bedroom, 1-bath ranch with a spacious 2-car garage in the back! It’s in a fantastic location, just a hop away from Columbian Park, the Zoo, local shops, and dining options, plus it's within walking distance to school and so much more! This property is currently rented out for $1,200 a month, with tenants covering all utilities, and the lease runs until 5/31/27. You’ll love the roomy yard and inviting front porch, perfect for entertaining or unwinding. Inside, you’ll find an unfinished basement and a formal dining room. Whether you want to keep it as a rental or use it as your starter home, the choice is yours! Please note, this property is being sold as-is. **It’s also part of a package deal with the property located at 1113 Sarasota Drive, Lafayette, IN. Reach out to the listing agent for more details!

NEW ON MARKET | SOUTH SIDE RANCH1113 Sarasota Drive, Lafayette, IN 47909Offered at $175,000.00Welcome to 1113 Sarasota D...
05/05/2026

NEW ON MARKET | SOUTH SIDE RANCH

1113 Sarasota Drive, Lafayette, IN 47909
Offered at $175,000.00

Welcome to 1113 Sarasota Drive, a charming ranch tucked away in Crestview! This lovely spot is in a fantastic location, close to schools, parks, walking trails, and a variety of local eateries, pubs, and grocery stores—everything you need is just a stone's throw away! It's an ideal choice for investors looking to add to their portfolio, currently renting for $950 a month with a lease that runs until September 25, 2026. The cozy home features 2 bedrooms, 1 bath, and hardwood floors inside. Plus, you'll enjoy a generous backyard and a private one-car garage. ***And here's a bonus: this property is part of a package deal with another single-family rental at 710 S 27th Street in Lafayette, IN. For more details, just reach out to the listing agent!

SOLD | 918 2ND ST., COVINGTON, IN I’m so excited for these two on their new home closing! This journey had its ups and d...
05/05/2026

SOLD | 918 2ND ST., COVINGTON, IN

I’m so excited for these two on their new home closing! This journey had its ups and downs, but it was definitely worth it. These siblings grew tired of renting and decided to team up to buy a house together, building equity and a solid foundation for their future independent homeownership! Thank you for allowing me to be part of your journey in securing your first home—I'm looking forward to seeing all the memories you'll create there! Cheers, 🥂

Buying a home can be a winding road, but with the right lender, realtor, inspector, and support team by your side, it’s absolutely achievable! Considering buying or selling? Give me a call, (765) 427-2501

NEW ON MARKET | NORTH END PROPERTY1029 N 6th Street, Lafayette, INOffered at $160,000.00Here’s a fantastic opportunity f...
05/04/2026

NEW ON MARKET | NORTH END PROPERTY

1029 N 6th Street, Lafayette, IN
Offered at $160,000.00

Here’s a fantastic opportunity for a single-family rental! This delightful home on N 6th Street is currently renting for $1,075 per month, with tenants covering all utilities. Its prime location is perfect for anyone wanting to be close to historic downtown or just a quick commute to West Lafayette and Purdue’s campus. You’ll find yourself just steps away from local restaurants, shops, and trails, plus easy access up Union to I65 or US 52. The property features a fully fenced backyard with rear parking and a lovely open porch to enjoy the nice weather. Inside, you’ll be welcomed by charming original hardwood floors. The main floor includes a cozy living room, a den, a formal dining room, a main floor bedroom, a kitchen, and a full bathroom. Head upstairs to discover a spacious rec room, another full bathroom, and a generously sized primary bedroom. **Please note, this property is being sold as-is and is part of a package deal that includes a triplex at 712/714 S 5th Street. Reach out to the agent for more details before showings!

NEW ON MARKET | DOWNTOWN TRIPLEX 712/714 S 5th Street, Lafayette, IN Offered at $209,900.00Welcome to this charming trip...
05/04/2026

NEW ON MARKET | DOWNTOWN TRIPLEX

712/714 S 5th Street, Lafayette, IN
Offered at $209,900.00

Welcome to this charming triplex, fully rented and situated in a fantastic part of town! This investment gem is just a stone's throw away from the historic downtown area. Tucked away off Kossith Street on S. 5th St., it features two roomy units on the main floor and a cozy unit upstairs. Utilities are conveniently included in the rent. Currently, it brings in $2,765 per month, with a planned increase to $2,870 starting on 6/1/26. Enjoy the benefits of owning a rental property where tenants can savor a spacious backyard, a peaceful street, and easy access to downtown amenities, along with a short commute across the bridge to campus! Utility info available upon request. Property is being sold as-is. **This property is part of a package deal with 1029 N 6th Street. Please reach out to the agent for all the details before scheduling a showing.

SOLD | 5845 HUSTON RD., WEST LAFAYETTE, INHuge congratulations to my buyer on closing on their new riverfront property! ...
05/03/2026

SOLD | 5845 HUSTON RD., WEST LAFAYETTE, IN

Huge congratulations to my buyer on closing on their new riverfront property! This one-of-a-kind home was definitely one of my favorites to sell, with its charming vintage cabin vibes. It's the perfect spot for embracing nature, enjoying some peace and privacy, and still being just a stone's throw from town. I’m so thrilled for you and can’t wait to see all the wonderful memories you'll create in this little paradise! Thank you for putting your trust in me and letting me be a part of this journey with you!

Address

133 N 4th Street, Suite 300
Lafayette, IN
47901

Opening Hours

Monday 8:30am - 10pm
Tuesday 8:30am - 10pm
Wednesday 8:30am - 10pm
Thursday 8:30am - 10pm
Friday 8:30am - 10pm
Saturday 8:30am - 10pm
Sunday 9:30am - 10pm

Telephone

+17654272501

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Tabitha Casto Real Estate Broker posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category