Tabitha Casto Real Estate Broker

06/19/2026

06/19/2026

SOLD | 625 ROBINSON ST., WEST LAFAYETTE, IN 47906

A big congratulations to my sellers on successfully selling their campus property! We moved quickly to get this one under contract and closed with a fantastic all-cash, no-inspection offer! As an agent, it truly means a lot to be chosen to represent clients, especially when they’re out-of-state and even more so when the client is an active broker themselves. Thank you for your trust in me throughout this process!

I also want to give a shout-out to the buyer and their agent – working with you was such a breeze, you all are a dream team!

06/19/2026

NEW ON MARKET | RENOVATED 1880's FARMHOUSE

652 S Main Street, Whitestown, IN 46075
Offered at $650,000.00

Welcome to this charming 1880 Farmhouse that’s been beautifully remodeled and boasts a fully finished basement, all nestled in the heart of downtown Whitestown! You'll instantly notice the stunning updates both inside and out as you approach the property, greeted by fresh landscaping, a lovely front fence, and a fabulous wraparound porch that’s ideal for sipping your morning coffee or hosting friends. At the end of the driveway, there’s a delightful custom chicken coop that the seller lovingly built, complete with solar-powered doors—your hens will feel right at home! Step inside and you’ll be welcomed by an inviting dining room and foyer, leading you to the kitchen of your dreams, featuring a spacious center island, a wine bar, stainless steel appliances, custom cabinets, a lovely backsplash, granite countertops, and a big walk-in pantry adorned with charming wallpaper. The family room offers a striking fireplace, and you’ll find a convenient half bath nearby along with a grand staircase showcasing original brick and vaulted ceilings. At the back, there’s a roomy laundry/mudroom that connects to a large two-car garage with a stylish epoxy floor and plenty of storage. Head upstairs to discover a cozy bedroom, a full bath and lovely vaulted beams, while the primary suite will take your breath away. It features a generous walk-in closet, a spacious bedroom area, a private reading nook, and an exquisite primary bath with a custom tile shower, dual shower heads, beautiful lighting, and double vanity sinks—perfect for starting your day right! In the basement, you’ll find another inviting living room with two additional bedrooms, another full bath, and an adorable sitting area at the bottom of the stairs, complete with personalized egress windows. Every inch of this home has been thoughtfully updated and designed. The backyard is fenced, and there's even a foundation started for a glass greenhouse. With a tree-lined driveway and spacious lot, this home enchants both inside and out. Featuring four bedrooms, 3.5 baths, high-end upgrades, and the perks of an HOA without the fees, this property is truly move-in ready! Don’t miss out, come see it today!

06/13/2026

SOLD | 222 FOREST HILL DR., WEST LAFAYETTE, IN 47906

What a heartwarming closing for some truly amazing people! Huge congratulations to my buyers on snagging their very first home! This lovely couple just welcomed their first little one and decided it was time to move back closer to friends and family. As luck would have it, we found a charming house right in one of the buyer's childhood neighborhoods! I can’t thank you enough for putting your trust in me during this journey, and welcome back to boiler country!

Referrals mean the world to me—they're the heartbeat of my business! I genuinely appreciate each one you send my way, and I always strive to exceed expectations. A huge thank you to all my past and current clients! It’s been an incredible year, and I truly appreciate your trust in me with your most important people.

06/11/2026

SOLD | 414 CINCINNATI STREET, LAFAYETTE, IN 47901

We’re absolutely thrilled to share that we've wrapped up this transaction! A huge congratulations to my sellers for successfully selling another property from their portfolio, and we hope the new owner enjoys this wonderful home!

Not every real estate journey is a walk in the park. Sometimes things can get a bit tricky, demanding, or even a little overwhelming. It's so important to choose the right person to represent you, especially when the deal gets tough. Having an agent who can think critically and creatively can make all the difference in getting to the closing table. So you better be sure to pick someone who’s committed to making the deal work, without their egos or fears getting in the way. This matters.

If you’re looking to buy or sell, let’s have a chat—feel free to reach out at (765) 427-2501!

06/09/2026

Click on the link below for more info and pictures of my newest listing! Don't hesitate to reach out to schedule a private tour.

Listed at $199,000, MLS #202622283, 2 beds, 1 bath, 1-car garage, 887 square feet, built in 1925, 0.1382, Welcome to this charming ranch home, perfectly situated on a cozy corner lot! With 2 lovely bedrooms and a bath, you’ll adore the original hardwood floors and the inviting fireplace in the liv...

06/09/2026

NEW ON MARKET | RANCH NEAR THE PARK

737 S 28th Street, Lafayette, IN 47904
Offered at $199,000.00

Welcome to this charming ranch home, perfectly situated on a cozy corner lot! With 2 lovely bedrooms and a bath, you’ll adore the original hardwood floors and the inviting fireplace in the living room. The detached one-car garage adds convenience, and both the adorable front and back porches are perfect spots to unwind and soak up nature. The bright kitchen is a delight, filled with sunshine. You’ll love the fenced-in backyard, which is ideal for pets, kids, and hosting fun get-togethers with friends and family. Plus, the full basement has laundry access and additional space for all your storage needs! Best of all, you’re just a hop away from local shops, Loeb Stadium, Columbian Park, the Zoo, and Tropicanoe Cove!

06/07/2026

Click on the link below for more info and photos of my newest listing! Don't hesitate to reach out for more details or schedule a private showing!

Listed at $199,000, MLS #202622080, 2 beds, 1 bath, 1-car garage, 1,012 square feet, built in 1930, 0.1516, Welcome to this lovely ranch home on S 29th Street, featuring a charming covered porch! This cozy 2-bedroom, 1-bath retreat is set on a neatly landscaped lot, complete with a fenced backyard a...

06/07/2026

NEW ON MARKET | COZY FRONT PORCH RANCH

309 S 29th Street, Lafayette, IN
Offered at $199,000.00

Welcome to this lovely ranch home on S 29th Street, featuring a charming covered porch! This cozy 2-bedroom, 1-bath retreat is set on a neatly landscaped lot, complete with a fenced backyard and a handy utility shed for all you gardening enthusiasts out there! You can kick back and relax in the inviting front enclosed porch or enjoy some social time on the back patio. The detached garage offers extra storage and enough space to park one vehicle comfortably. Inside, you'll be greeted by original hardwood floors that flow through the living room, first bedroom, dining and back bedroom. There's also a delightful formal dining room right off the cute kitchen! The primary bedroom is located at the back of the dining room, and you’ll find a convenient main floor laundry that leads to the basement and a back door out to the yard. This home has been lovingly maintained by its previous owners and is just waiting for you to add your personal touch and turn it into your own personalized oasis!

06/06/2026

Check out the property link below for more info and photos!

Listed at $409,900, MLS #202620104, 4 beds, 2.5 baths, 2-car garage, 2,273 square feet, built in 1930, 0.1025, Welcome to this delightful two-story home located on a picturesque street, just a short stroll from Purdue's campus! This stunning house makes a fantastic first impression, sitting on a cor...