What are the opening hours?

Monday 9am - 5pm Tuesday 9am - 5pm Wednesday 9am - 5pm Thursday 9am - 5pm Friday 9am - 5pm Saturday 9am - 5pm Sunday 9am - 5pm

Amy P. - Buy FL Keys Homes

Name: Amy P. - Buy FL Keys Homes
Address: 11050 Overseas Highway, Marathon, FL, 33050, US
Telephone: +13057661745

Home
United States
Marathon, FL
Amy P. - Buy FL Keys Homes

Amy Puto, 25 years of local real estate expertise in the Florida Keys. Member of Coldwell Banker Schmitt Elite Agent Circle (top 100 agents Keys-wide).

Specializing in waterfront homes, condos, and resort properties from Marathon to Islamorada.

05/30/2026

🌊 Just Listed in Key Colony Beach! 🌊

Looking for your own quiet coastal sanctuary? Welcome to The Cay Condominium (Unit 316-D), where oceanfront paradise is right outside your door!

This pristine, never-before-rented 2-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom townhouse-style condo offers 1,343 sq. ft. of beautifully updated living space. Because it's laid out over two stories, it feels much more like a private home than a typical condo.

✨ Property Highlights:
Stunning Views: Enjoy gorgeous ocean views from your living room balcony, the primary suite, and the guest bedroom—plus bonus sunset views from the guest balcony!

Beautifully Updated: Features luxury vinyl plank flooring downstairs, a fully renovated kitchen, stylishly updated baths, and brand-new carpeting upstairs.

Natural Soundtrack: Situated just one unit back from the open ocean, you can leave your windows open at night and fall asleep to the gentle sound of the ocean.

Premium Amenities: Relax by the sparkling heated pool, gather in the oceanfront community room, or sink your toes into the sandy beach complete with a classic tiki hut.

🌴 The Key Colony Beach Lifestyle
Located in "The Gem of the Florida Keys," this property lets you fully immerse yourself in an incredible, relaxed island community. Enjoy dedicated walking and bike paths, Sunset Park, a par-3 golf course, tennis and pickleball courts, plus vibrant waterfront dining and charter boats just minutes away.

📌 Investor Note: The Cay features a 14-day minimum rental restriction. It’s perfect for generating excellent rental income while maintaining a peaceful, exclusive atmosphere that doesn't feel like a busy, high-turnover hotel.

📍 601 W Ocean Dr 316-D, Key Colony, FL 33051
💰 Offered at $649,000

Want to see it in person? Message me directly or call today to schedule your private showing!

Link to more photos and info in the Comments.

Amy P**o 📞 305-766-1745
📧 [email protected]
Coldwell Banker Schmitt Real Estate Co.

05/19/2026

⚓ Just Listed: Bring Your Boat to the Boat House Marina! ⚓

Looking for the perfect home base for your vessel in Marathon? Slip 32 at the Boat House Marina is officially on the market and ready for its next owner!

Whether you’re a local looking for a dedicated slip or want a secure spot in the Heart of the Keys with "weekend getaway" perks, this is a fantastic opportunity to secure your own piece of the waterfront.

Property Highlights:

Size: 40' wet slip (accommodates up to 40' LOA) with a 13.42' width.

Location: 12399 Overseas Hwy, Slip 32, Marathon, FL 33050 (Mile Marker 53 - Ocean Side).

Easy Access: Quick, effortless access to both the Atlantic Ocean and the Gulf of Mexico for all your fishing, diving, and cruising adventures. 🌊

Price: $175,000

The Ultimate Weekend Getaway:
What makes this slip truly special? The marina allows owners to stay on board for up to 5 consecutive nights (with a maximum of 10 nights per month)—making it the perfect private retreat for your Keys vacations!

First-Class Marina Amenities:

On-site dockmaster & fuel station ⛽

Community pool 🏊‍♂️

Boat ramp & fish cleaning tiki station 🎣

50-amp electrical service (metered separately) and water included in your monthly association fees.

Skip the hassle of long ramp lines and secure a permanent home for your boat in a highly desirable Marathon location.

Link to more details and pics in the Comments.

Call/text me today at 305-766-1745 for more details or to secure this slip before the weekend!

05/16/2026

🚨 JUST REDUCED & TURNKEY READY! 🚨
260 Sadowski Causeway, Key Colony Beach, FL 💰 NOW: $1,375,000

Looking for the ultimate Florida Keys waterfront investment or your own private tropical paradise? This is the one you’ve been waiting for! 🌴✨

This immaculate, ground-level 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom "Ellison" half-duplex offers the perfect blend of luxury, convenience, and proven income potential. Best of all? NO STAIRS to climb!

🛥️ BOATER’S DREAM SETUP
46 Feet of Canal Frontage with a step-down dock.

Quick, seamless ocean access for world-class fishing, diving, and cruising.

Concrete seawall and built-in fish cleaning station.

💰 PROVEN INVESTMENT POWERHOUSE
Established Weekly Vacation Rental for over 10 years!

Generates an impressive average of $135K–$140K in annual gross income.

Boasts a spectacular booking history, renting 49 weeks per year with strong future bookings already in place.

🏡 PROPERTY HIGHLIGHTS
Bright, open-concept living space with beautiful tile flooring throughout.

Spacious kitchen featuring granite countertops and stainless steel appliances.

Step right out to your private pool overlooking the wide, clean canal.

Located in highly desirable Key Colony Beach—just minutes from Sunset Park beach, golf, tennis, pickleball, and local favorites like Havana Jack’s!

Whether you are looking to expand your rental portfolio with a turnkey money-maker or want a slice of paradise all to yourself, this property delivers on every level.

Don't wait—at this newly reduced price, it won't last long!

Link with more details and photos in the comments.

📲 DM or call me at 305-766-1745 to schedule your private showing

05/15/2026

🌊 Rare Opportunity for Large Yachts in Boot Key Harbor!

Looking for a home for a larger vessel? Slip B1 at Sombrero Marina is now available and offers a rare combination of size, security, and lifestyle in the heart of Marathon.

This isn’t just a lease—this is owned baybottom, providing the stability of ownership and the highly coveted full-time liveaboard status.

⚓ Key Features:

Massive Dimensions: Per survey, the slip is 87' long and over 20' wide (21.64' at the outside pilings).

Yacht Ready: Accommodates vessels up to 75' LOA with a max beam of 18'9" (per dockmaster).

Prime Location: Located in the protected waters of Boot Key Harbor with deep water access.

Convenience: Just steps away from Dockside for food and drinks and laundry facilities and showers.

Flexibility: Use it as your permanent island residence, a seasonal home for your yacht, or have the on-site dockmaster rent it out when you’re away.

Price: $375,000 | The Seller is open to offers!

Financing is also available through a local bank to help make your Florida Keys transition seamless.

Ready to see it?
Check out the photos in the link below or message me for more details.
https://marathonfloridakeysrealestate.com/sombrero-marina-b1/

05/14/2026

Coldwell Banker Schmitt Real Estate Company (CBSREC), based on dollar volume of sales for 2025, was ranked among the most successful real estate companies in the United States, appearing at

05/08/2026

Rare Live-Aboard Opportunity: Slip 7 at Harbour Cay Club! ⛵

If you’ve been searching for a deep-water home for your vessel in the Heart of the Keys, this is it. Located in a gated and meticulously maintained marina on the Gulf side of Marathon, Slip 7 offers a premier live-aboard experience.

Key Features & Specs:

Size: 52’ dock length; accommodates up to 48’ LOA.

Deep Water: 7’ controlling depth for peace of mind.

Extras: Two dock boxes are included with the sale!

Financing: Seller financing is possible with just 20% down.

Life at Harbour Cay Club:
This isn't just a place to tie up—it's a community. Harbour Cay is known for being exceptionally well-kept with amenities that make life on the water easy and enjoyable:

The Clubhouse: A full community building with a kitchen, living area, laundry, and spotless bath/shower facilities.

Guest Housing: A charming 1BR/1BA apartment is available for your guests (or for you during haul-out) for a minimal fee.

For the Maker: A standout, well-equipped workshop perfect for all your DIY boat projects and maintenance.

Island Perks: On-site boat ramp, kayak/paddleboard storage, trailer storage, and a covered pavilion for those breathtaking sunset views.

Price: $195,000

More info and pics: https://marathonfloridakeysrealestate.com/1466-overseas-7/

Location: 1466 Overseas Hwy Slip 7, Marathon, FL 33050

Important Requirements: Membership approval by Harbour Cay Club is required. Buyers must have their vessel at the time of the offer for physical inspection and club approval.

Ready to make the move to the Marathon waterfront? DM me or call 305-766-1745 for more details or to schedule a private tour!

05/06/2026

🏖️ Coastal Comfort at Sea Isle – Key Colony Beach

Looking for a peaceful oceanfront escape where the Atlantic is your front yard? This 2BR/2BA condo at Sea Isle (Unit 24) offers the perfect balance of island relaxation and convenience.

This isn’t just a place to stay—it’s a place to truly unwind. Whether you are looking for a seasonal getaway or a full-time residence, this turnkey unit makes island living effortless.

Why This Unit Stands Out:

Ocean Views: The primary bedroom features its own private balcony—the perfect spot for your morning coffee while watching the sunrise over the water. ☕️🌅

Move-In Ready: Beautifully maintained with a granite kitchen, updated baths and spacious living area. It comes fully furnished, so you can start enjoying the Keys immediately.

Relaxed Lifestyle: Step directly onto one of the most beautiful sandy beaches in the area or enjoy a quiet afternoon by the sparkling community pool. 🏊‍♂️🏖️

The Sea Isle Advantage:
Owners at Sea Isle enjoy a meticulously cared-for complex with assigned parking and a friendly, quiet atmosphere. While the building allows weekly rentals—providing a great way to help offset your carrying costs and insurance—it remains a peaceful retreat for those who value a relaxed island pace.

Key Colony Beach Living:
Known as the "Gem of the Florida Keys," Key Colony Beach is a premier resort community. You’re just a short walk or bike ride away from local restaurants, golf, sports courts, and Sunset Park. 🚲🌴

Quick Specs:

Price: $399,999

More info and pics: https://marathonfloridakeysrealestate.com/sea-isle-24/

Location: 1101 W Ocean Dr #24, Key Colony Beach, FL 33051

Features: 2 Bedrooms, 2 Baths, Oceanfront Complex

Ready to trade the hustle and bustle for toes in the sand? Message me today for more details or to schedule a private showing!

05/04/2026

New Live-Aboard Opportunity in Marathon! ⚓️

Looking for the perfect spot to call home on the water? Slip 6 at Harbour Cay Club is now available and ready for its next owner. This isn’t just a boat slip; it’s a lifestyle in an immaculately maintained, 24-slip live-aboard marina.

Property Highlights:

Capacity: Accommodates up to a 48' LOA with a 52' dock length.

Deep Water Access: 7' controlling depth (per dockmaster).

Location: Protected basin on the Gulf side—perfect for catching those famous Florida Keys sunsets from the community pavilion.

Recent Upgrades: Brand new decking just installed on the finger pier!

Why You’ll Love Harbour Cay Club:

This gated community is packed with amenities that make island living easy:

Clubhouse & Social Spaces: Full kitchen, dining area, and a 1-bedroom guest apartment available for your visitors.

Convenience: On-site laundry, well-equipped workshop, BBQ grills, and an ice machine.

Storage: Kayak/paddleboard racks and boat trailer storage (as available).

Bonus: A small boat basin for vessels up to 23.5' is also available for an additional fee.

Price: $195,000

More info and pics: https://marathonfloridakeysrealestate.com/1466-overseas-6/

Location: 1466 Overseas Hwy Slip 6, Marathon, FL 33050

Seller will consider financing with 50% down!

Important Note: Membership approval by Harbour Cay Club is required, and buyers must have a boat at the time of the offer for physical inspection and approval by the club.

Don't miss out on this gem in the Heart of the Keys. Message me or call me at 305-766-1745 to schedule a showing!

05/01/2026

🛥️ Just Sold: Double-Closing in Marathon!

Big news today at The Boat House Marina! I just closed on two fantastic dry storage solutions that solve the biggest headaches for Keys boaters looking to get out of the sun and into the barn:

1. The "Tall Tower" Solution (Units 16B & 16C)
This rare double-rack in the storage barn is a total game-changer. With a massive 22.55' height clearance, it’s one of the only indoor dry-slips in the Middle Keys capable of housing vessels with tall towers and large dimensions. Sold for $160,000. https://marathonfloridakeysrealestate.com/boat-house-16bc/

2. The "Wide Load" Advantage (Unit 66A)
I also closed on this premium single rack, which is a rare find for wider boats. It offers a foot of extra width compared to the average rack, making it the perfect fit for those beamy center consoles. Sold for $177,000. https://marathonfloridakeysrealestate.com/boat-house-66a/

Both owners are now set for the ultimate concierge lifestyle—no more trailering! They’ll enjoy on-site fuel, a private ramp, and instant access to the Atlantic or Gulf via Vaca Cut.

Ready to move your boat indoors and start relaxing? Whether you are buying or selling your "home" in the barn or your waterfront home or condo, let me put my 25 years of experience as Keys Realtor to work for you.

Address

11050 Overseas Highway
Marathon, FL
33050

Opening Hours

Monday	9am - 5pm
Tuesday	9am - 5pm
Wednesday	9am - 5pm
Thursday	9am - 5pm
Friday	9am - 5pm
Saturday	9am - 5pm
Sunday	9am - 5pm

Telephone

+13057661745

Website

https://marathonfloridakeysrealestate.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Amy P. - Buy FL Keys Homes posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Amy P. - Buy FL Keys Homes:

Shortcuts

Address
Telephone
Opening Hours
Alerts
Contact The Business
Claim ownership or report listing

Want your business to be the top-listed Realtor/realty Service in Marathon?