Cara Benak - Nashville Realtor

Cara Benak - Nashville Realtor Licensed Realtor® serving the Nashville area. I provide an individualized experience for all! Cara's business is built on authenticity, communication, and trust.

Originally an Alabama native, Cara always dreamed of living in the Nashville area. After graduating from Auburn University in 2020, Cara moved to Brentwood and is currently residing in the Germantown area. Cara is now a licensed REALTOR® and specializes in first-time home buyers. Cara has intimate knowledge of the area and a strong desire to make her home your home! Having worked in education in N

ashville, Cara is confident that her knowledge of Nashville's school systems will aid families with the ability to choose their perfect Nashville location! This combination has equipped her with the ability to actively listen to her clients and use that information to construct an experience specific to their needs. Whether you are a first-time home buyer, an experienced home buyer, an investor, or interested in selling your home, Cara is there to provide a smooth and easy experience! When you're ready, she's there. Give her a call - (334) 718-4600.

UNDER CONTRACT 🔑New construction has a reputation for being the easy button. Walk into the model home, meet the sales re...
08/01/2026

UNDER CONTRACT 🔑

New construction has a reputation for being the easy button. Walk into the model home, meet the sales rep, sign the builder’s paperwork, pick your finishes. And honestly, it can be that smooth. But smooth and protected aren’t the same thing.

Here’s what I want more buyers to know: the person at the desk in that model home is very good at their job, and their job is representing the builder. That’s not a criticism, it’s just the arrangement. You’re allowed to bring your own agent into that conversation, and in almost every case it costs you nothing to do it.

My client is one of the most numbers-driven buyers I’ve worked with. He’d done the research, he knew what he wanted, and he was fully prepared to walk. So we treated a new build like any other negotiation.

Highlights:
• $15,000 in seller-paid closing costs, structured so it could go toward buying points instead of just absorbing fees ✅
• He kept his own lender rather than defaulting to the builder’s in-house option 🤝
• A full inspection with our inspector, on a home the builder doesn’t typically open up that way 🔍
• Written commitment on defects and cosmetic touch-ups from the blue tape walk 🏡
• A closing date set around his timeline

None of that was sitting on the table when we started. All of it came from asking, and from being willing to hear no a few times first.

If you’re touring new construction this year, the thing to understand is that the contract in front of you was written by the builder, for the builder. That’s normal. It’s also negotiable more often than people assume. You can use your own lender. You can ask for more toward closing. You can ask what happens if the inspection turns something up.

You just have to know to ask, and it helps to have someone in your corner who does this every week.

Follow Cara Benak | Nashville Realtor for the parts of Nashville real estate that don’t make it into the listing!

Cara Benak
The Costigan Group | Compass Tennessee

firsttimehomebuyer movingtonashville

UNDER CONTRACT 🔑New construction has a reputation for being the easy button. Walk into the model home, meet the sales re...
08/01/2026

UNDER CONTRACT 🔑

New construction has a reputation for being the easy button. Walk into the model home, meet the sales rep, sign the builder’s paperwork, pick your finishes. And honestly, it can be that smooth. But smooth and protected aren’t the same thing.

Here’s what I want more buyers to know: the person at the desk in that model home is very good at their job, and their job is representing the builder. That’s not a criticism, it’s just the arrangement. You’re allowed to bring your own agent into that conversation, and in almost every case it costs you nothing to do it.

My client is one of the most numbers-driven buyers I’ve worked with. He’d done the research, he knew what he wanted, and he was fully prepared to walk. So we treated a new build like any other negotiation.

Highlights:
• $15,000 in seller-paid closing costs, structured so it could go toward buying points instead of just absorbing fees ✅
• He kept his own lender rather than defaulting to the builder’s in-house option 🤝
• A full inspection with our inspector, on a home the builder doesn’t typically open up that way 🔍
• Written commitment on defects and cosmetic touch-ups from the blue tape walk 🏡
• A closing date set around his timeline

None of that was sitting on the table when we started. All of it came from asking, and from being willing to hear no a few times first.

If you’re touring new construction this year, the thing to understand is that the contract in front of you was written by the builder, for the builder. That’s normal. It’s also negotiable more often than people assume. You can use your own lender. You can ask for more toward closing. You can ask what happens if the inspection turns something up.

You just have to know to ask, and it helps to have someone in your corner who does this every week.

Follow Cara Benak | Nashville Realtor for the parts of Nashville real estate that don’t make it into the listing!

Cara Benak
The Costigan Group Compass Tennessee

firsttimehomebuyer movingtonashville

I help people figure out where they actually want to live in Nashville, not just which house to buy.If you’re moving her...
07/12/2026

I help people figure out where they actually want to live in Nashville, not just which house to buy.

If you’re moving here (or just thinking about a different neighborhood), send me a DM. I’d love to help you narrow it down. 🤍

NashvilleHomes EastNashville CompassRealEstate

Walk to coffee in the nations!Walk the dog at West Park!Grab dinner without moving your car!Then come home to:- a true T...
02/21/2026

Walk to coffee in the nations!
Walk the dog at West Park!
Grab dinner without moving your car!

Then come home to:
- a true TWO CAR garage
- professionally installed EV charger
- private bathrooms for every bedroom

THIS is convenient Nashville living.

Who do you see living here?

Open House Sunday from 2-4
732 James Ave

Inspection reports are long, detailed, and often overwhelming.Most of the stress comes from treating every note as equal...
01/28/2026

Inspection reports are long, detailed, and often overwhelming.
Most of the stress comes from treating every note as equally serious when it’s not.

A little structure changes everything.

Rates are down, but this dynamic duo is still UP. Ready to team up with the girls that get it done?Message us!
09/18/2025

Rates are down, but this dynamic duo is still UP. Ready to team up with the girls that get it done?

Message us!

Address

Nashville, TN
37201-37250

Telephone

+13347184600

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Cara Benak - Nashville Realtor posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Cara Benak - Nashville Realtor:

Shortcuts

Share

Category