The Baumgartner Group, Keller Williams

Home
United States
New Berlin, WI
The Baumgartner Group, Keller Williams

Your Trusted Advisors in Real Estate

•Career sales in excess of $350 Million
•More than 47 Years of combined Real Estate Experience
• #1 in the New Berlin Office for 9 consecutive years in both total Sales & Units
•Top 1% of All Metro-Milwaukee MLS Realtors®
•Top 1% Nationally
•Associate Vice President
•President's Club Member
•Featured annually in Milwaukee Magazine's Five Star: Best in Client
Satisfaction issue

About The Team:

•Jay Baumgartner has more than 19 years selling residential real estate, and graduated from the Business School at the University of Wisconsin-Madison in 2001 with a Business and Marketing Degree.

•Sara Baumgartner has more than 19 years selling residential real estate, and graduated from the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee in 2001 with a Computer Science degree.

•Julie Baumgartner has more than 30 years selling residential real estate in the Metro-Milwaukee and surrounding areas.

09/25/2026

🍎 3 Apple Orchards Near Milwaukee to visit this Fall 🍎

Looking for a fun fall outing? Add these local favorites to your list:

🍎 Basse’s Country Delight — Muskego
📍 S70W16050 Janesville Road, Muskego

A family-owned Muskego favorite since 1936, Basse’s Market offers apples, pumpkins, mums, cider, pies, hot game on Sundays and warm apple cider donuts.

Basse’s is offering U-Pick on September 26–27 and October 3–4, featuring Honeycrisp and Gala apples in their picturesque orchard. It’s a classic fall tradition close to home. 🍂

🍏 Peck & Bushel Fruit Company — Colgate
📍 5454 County Road Q, Colgate

About 30 minutes northwest of Milwaukee, this certified-organic orchard offers scenic apple picking, fresh cider, homemade pies and famous apple cider donuts.

You can also enjoy lunch at the on-site cidery and capture beautiful fall photos among the orchard rows. 🍎📸

🍎 Patterson Orchards — New Berlin
📍 4607 South 124th Street, New Berlin

This longtime local farm market offers 33 varieties of apples, along with fresh cider, caramel apples, pies, seasonal produce and other fall favorites.

Visit for a classic Wisconsin farm-market experience and pick up everything you need for a cozy autumn day at home. 🍂

Which orchard will you visit this fall?

09/23/2026

🏡 NEW LISTING in WAUKESHA! 🏡

1344 Moccasin Trail, Waukesha
4 BR | 2.5 BA | 2,735 SQ FT | $739,990

Move-in ready!

This new construction 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath Colonial offers 2,735 square feet of impressive finishes & functional design.

The stunning eat-in kitchen includes an abundance of cabinetry with crown molding, soft-close drawers, quartz countertop, island and walk-in pantry! Corner gas fireplace with stone surround in the inviting living room plus an additional flex room. Convenient mudroom with built-in storage lockers.

Four bedrooms upstairs including the spacious owner’s suite complete with two walk-in closets, tile bath with split vanities and dual-head walk-in shower.

Unfinished lower level with egress window & rough-in for future full bath. Other features include 9-foot ceiling (main floor), wide baseboards, 4-car garage and driveway/landscaping included!

This is a value buy!

📩 Message us for more details or to schedule your private showing.

Jay & Sara Baumgartner
📞(262) 202-1617 (call or text)
🌎 thebaumgartnergroup.com

09/09/2026

✨⭐️ SOLD and CLOSED!! ⭐️✨

🎉 Congratulations 🎉 to our Buyers on the purchase of their beautiful new home in Milwaukee! 🏡

Purchasing your first home is an exciting time. We are thankful that we were able to help walk them through the process.

Wishing them many happy memories in their new home! ❤️

Thinking about buying, building, or selling? Let’s talk—we’d love to help you make your next move!

Jay & Sara Baumgartner
☎️(262) 202-1617
🌎thebaumgartnergroup.com

09/03/2026

🏡 NEW TO THE MARKET in WAUKESHA! 🏡

1823 Deer Path, Waukesha
4 BR | 3.5 BA | 3,194 SQ FT | $627,900

Outstanding 4 bedroom, 3.5 bath Contemporary boasts over 2,400 square feet above-grade plus a beautifully finished lower-level! The gas fireplace with stone surround is the focal point of the inviting living room.

An abundance of raised-panel cabinetry in the eat-in kitchen complete with new quartz countertop, backsplash and natural hardwood flooring.

The thoughtfully designed floorplan includes a formal dining room, home office and family room. Four spacious bedrooms upstairs including the owner’s suite with private full bath and walk-in closet.

The exposed lower level offers a large entertainment space plus full bath. Relax on the expansive rear deck overlooking a nicely manicured backyard.

Updated roof (2025), central air (2026), newer hardwood flooring, water heater & patio door.

📩 Message us for more details or to schedule your private showing.

Jay & Sara Baumgartner
📞(262) 202-1617 (call or text)
🌎 thebaumgartnergroup.com

08/28/2026

🏡 NEW LISTING in WAUKESHA! 🏡

1823 Deer Path, Waukesha
4 BR | 3.5 BA | 3,194 SQ FT | $627,900

Outstanding 4 bedroom, 3.5 bath Contemporary boasts over 2,400 square feet above-grade plus a beautifully finished lower-level! The gas fireplace with stone surround is the focal point of the inviting living room.

An abundance of raised-panel cabinetry in the eat-in kitchen complete with new quartz countertop, backsplash and natural hardwood flooring.

The thoughtfully designed floorplan includes a formal dining room, home office and family room. Four spacious bedrooms upstairs including the owner’s suite with private full bath and walk-in closet.

The exposed lower level offers a large entertainment space plus full bath. Relax on the expansive rear deck overlooking a nicely manicured backyard.

Updated roof (2025), central air (2026), newer hardwood flooring, water heater & patio door.

📩 Message us for more details or to schedule your private showing.

Jay & Sara Baumgartner
📞(262) 202-1617 (call or text)
🌎 thebaumgartnergroup.com

08/19/2026

🏡 NEW TO THE MARKET IN MUSKEGO! 🏡

Goes LIVE THURSDAY, 8/20!

W154S7609 Rain Tree Court, Muskego
4 BR | 3 BA | 2,868 SQ FT | $724,900

Take a sneak peek at this quality-built 4 BR, 3 BA split Muskego ranch!

Floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace, 12-foot cathedral ceilings, expansive kitchen, amazing finished lower level and 3 car garage all on a mature 1/2 acre lot are just a few of the highlights.

Updates include central air (‘21), water heater (‘24), newer storm windows and updated carpeting. Goes live 8/20!

📩 Message us for more details or to schedule your private showing.

Jay & Sara Baumgartner
📞(262) 202-1617 (call or text)
🌎 thebaumgartnergroup.com

08/17/2026

The perfect spot to enjoy your morning coffee or summer evenings with family and friends.

Showings start this Thursday - 8/20

W154S7609 Rain Tree Court, Muskego
4 BR | 3 BA | 2,868 SQ FT | $724,900

Message us for more details or to schedule your private showing.

Jay & Sara Baumgartner
📞(262) 202-1617 (call or text)
🌎 thebaumgartnergroup.com

08/13/2026

🏡 COMING SOON in MUSKEGO! 🏡

W154S7609 Rain Tree Court, Muskego
4 BR | 3 BA | 2,868 SQ FT | $724,900

Take a sneak peek at this quality-built 4 BR, 3 BA split Muskego ranch!

Floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace, 12-foot cathedral ceilings, expansive kitchen, amazing finished lower level and 3 car garage all on a mature 1/2 acre lot are just a few of the highlights.

Updates include: central air (‘21), water heater (‘24), newer storm windows and updated carpeting.

Goes live 8/20!

📩 Message us for more details or to schedule your private showing.

Jay & Sara Baumgartner
📞(262) 202-1617 (call or text)
🌎 thebaumgartnergroup.com

08/08/2026

🌟 NEW PRICE!! 🌟

Featuring more than 2,000 square feet, this new construction 3 bedroom, 2 bath ranch boasts an impressive open-concept floorplan and modern amenities!

Staggered cabinetry in the kitchen complete with crown molding, soft close doors & drawers, solid surface countertop and center island. Vaulted ceiling in the living room with laminate flooring, gas fireplace and surround.

Private owner’s suite with tray ceiling, walk-in closet and beautiful tile bathroom with dual-sink vanity and walk-in shower.

Convenient main floor laundry with cabinet, sink and drywalled locker storage! Lower level basement includes large egress window, high efficiency furnace, 200-amp electrical service, low-maintenance exterior plus a four-car garage (tandem), concrete drive, front walkway, rear patio and sod.

Now offered at $699,990

Interested in touring this home?
Have questions on building a home?
Contact us today! 📞

Jay & Sara Baumgartner
☎️(262) 202-1617
🌎thebaumgartnergroup.com

04/17/2026

Framing and drywall are done and we have moved on to the stage where the house really starts to come to life! ✨

At our latest site visit to our new construction property in Dousman, the carpenters had begun installing trim and hanging doors. It’s always exciting to see these finishing touches go in because suddenly the spaces feel more defined—and more like home.

Here, Jay gives us a quick update on the construction progress.

We can’t wait to share more progress as this beautiful home comes together! Next up: tile! 🏡

Jay & Sara Baumgartner
☎️ (262) 202-1617
🌎 thebaumgartnergroup.com

Address

2665 South Moorland Road, Suite 104
New Berlin, WI
53151

Website

http://www.tbgsells.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Baumgartner Group, Keller Williams posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Baumgartner Group, Keller Williams:

Want your business to be the top-listed Realtor/realty Service in New Berlin?