12/06/2020
A Comparison of the Carbon Footprint of a Forestry Operation in Wendell State Forest with the Carbon Footprint of the Residents of Wendell, MA.
A small group of anti-forestry extremists protested a forestry operation in Wendell state forest and even sued the state to try and stop it. They falsely claimed that it would cause a massive release of CO2 and help “fuel climate change”. In this research paper, we did a comparative study to examine the facts.
Forest Cutting Plan for Wendell State Forest – 2018 – We obtained a copy of the plan after making a Public Records Request.
Location: Montague & Brook Road, Wendell State Forest, Wendell, MA
Acres Cut: 117 Acres Volume Harvested: 550 MBF, 369 cords or 1469 cords (2 cords = 1 MBF).
Harvard Forest concluded that growth rates for forests in this area are in the range of approximately 2/3 cord/acre/year using “conventional” rather than “highly intensive” forest management. Using that growth rate, those 117 acres will grow (117 x .2/3) 78 cords/year or 1482 cords over 19 years. So the volume that was cut will grow back in about 19 years. Cutting cycle = 15-25 years so the harvest intensity fits nicely inside the cutting cycle for sustainable forestry.
The fuel use from logging & trucking releases .05 tons of CO2/cord harvested so 1469 x .05 = 73 tons of CO2 that were released by the timber harvest at Wendell State Forest. That amount of CO2 will be re-sequestered by the area that was harvested (117 acres) in about one year.
The sawlogs that were cut were sold to regional sawmills that will produce lumber and other forest products that will sequester CO2 for a very long period of time. The cordwood that was harvested will reduce the use of imported heating oil greatly reducing the carbon footprint for home heating. The managed forest also provides many other benefits such as: lower tree mortality which means lower CO2 and methane emission rates; higher rates of CO2 sequestration because of higher growth rates; the growth of more high quality timber provides a better product mix for long-term wood use (more sawlogs and less pulpwood and firewood) and other product replacement such as wooden furniture, flooring, and other wood products from the harvested timber which replaces plastic/metal/synthetics that use more CO2 to process and create more pollution and are not renewable resources. Finally, the managed forest provides for more diverse wildlife habitat.
Add it all up and you can see that forest management is not only good for our economy but good for our environment and the climate.
Now let’s compare the carbon footprint for Wendell residents to the forestry work done in Wendell State Forest:
390 households in Wendell –
1500 square feet/house for the average modest house. An average of 4 new houses are built every year in Wendell = 6,000 square feet. 16,000 board feet of lumber and wood panels are used for each new house or an equivalent of 33 cords. 33 x 4 = 132 cords x 2.5 tons/cord = 330 tons of carbon in new house construction. The 1500 square foot house also needs a foundation which uses about 134 tons of concrete whose manufacture produces another 134 tons of CO2 emissions. 134 x 4 = 534 tons.
At least ½ of households use some wood heat – 5 cords/year = 1,000 cords/year = 2,600 tons of carbon/year
80% of households heat with oil. The average house uses at least 500 gallons/year. So about 312 households (.8 x 390) use 500 x 312 = 156,000 gallons of heating oil every year. .0113 tons/gallon of heating oil emits 1 ton of CO2 so 1,762 tons of CO2 are emitted every year from burning heating oil.
Propane for cooking – average of 3 gallons/month x 390 = 1,170 x 12 months = 14,040 gallons/year. .0063 tons of CO2/gallon propane = 88 tons of CO2/year
Municipal Solid Waste (MSW) generated in 2017 increased to 4.51 pounds per person per day. Paper and paperboard products made up the largest percentage of all the materials in MSW, at 25 percent of total generation. = 2 lbs. per household/day = 730 lbs./year x 390 households = 284,700 lbs./year = 142 tons/year for the town of Wendell. That does not include any yard waste.
Average miles driven per licensed driver in MA = 12,000 miles/year. A typical passenger vehicle emits about .000453 tons of CO2/mile. The population in Wendell was 848 at the 2010 census. Assume 70% are licensed drivers based on MA statistics then there are 594 licensed drivers in Wendell driving an average of 12,000 miles/year or a total or 7,128,000 total miles emitting a total of 3,229 tons of CO2 every year.
Average CO2 emissions per capita in Massachusetts every year from electricity generation = 1.3 tons/person. 848 x 1.3 = 1,100 tons
Approximate Carbon Footprint of the people of Wendell every year:
New House Construction – 330 tons for wood and 534 tons for concrete
Wood Heat – 2,600 tons
Oil Heat – 1,762 tons
Propane – 88 tons
Municipal Solid Waste – 142 tons
Car/truck transportation – 3,229 tons
Electricity - 534 tons
Total Carbon Footprint for the Town of Wendell every year:
9,219 tons
These are approximate tonnages. If you wanted really accurate numbers you would have to survey each household.
The anti-forestry protesters in Wendell say we need to shut down all forestry operations on over 600,000 acres of state forest because we are in a “climate emergency”. Yet look at all the emissions they are generating while the forestry work in Wendell State Forest that they were protesting is carbon neutral within a normal cutting cycle.
CO2 emissions from forestry operations are not a problem. The problem is that we need more forest management not less. And if you are concerned with CO2 emissions, you should try and reduce your own carbon footprint rather than trying to shut down forestry operations which provide the forest products that we all use and depend on.
Photo: A nicely thinned red oak forest stand after the forestry operation in Wendell State Forest.
Mike Leonard, Consulting Forester
North Quabbin Forestry
33 Leighton Road
Petersham, MA 01366