05/16/2026
✨ A Rare Opportunity to Own One of Owasco Lake’s Most Iconic Waterfront Estates ✨
🏡 4 Beds | 2.5 Baths | 3,042 sq. ft
🌊 610 Feet of Shoreline | 1.9 Acres
📍 5072 W Lake Rd, Auburn, NY 13021 • Owasco Lake
💲 Offered at $1,900,000
Welcome to Fay’s Point Beach House, a truly extraordinary waterfront estate steeped in Finger Lakes history. Originally dating back to 1912, this iconic residence sits on one of the most remarkable settings on Owasco Lake with panoramic water views on three sides.
Set on 1.9 acres with approximately 610 feet of shoreline, the property offers a level of privacy, scale, and presence that is nearly impossible to replicate today. From the manicured grounds and stone seawall to the waterfront gazebo and sweeping lake views, every inch of this property feels timeless.
Inside, the home retains the warmth and craftsmanship of a true historic lakeside residence with rich original woodwork, hardwood floors, beamed ceilings, walls of windows, and three stunning fireplaces. The expansive lakeside living room was designed for gathering and entertaining while taking in breathtaking 270 degree views of the lake throughout every season.
The kitchen features handcrafted black walnut cabinetry built over 50 years ago, while the flexible floor plan includes four bedrooms, two full baths, a half bathroom, first floor laundry, and a lakeside study perfect for a home office or writer’s retreat.
Included additional lots across West Lake Road offer rare flexibility for additional parking, privacy, or future hospitality and development opportunities.
Fay’s Point Beach House is more than a home. It is a legacy property and one of the Finger Lakes’ truly special offerings.
📅 Private showings available by appointment only.
Link for 3D virtual tour:
https://youriguide.com/5072_w_lake_rd_auburn_ny
Steven Barrett
NYS Licensed Real Estate Broker
📞 315.882.0027
✉️ [email protected]
