06/17/2026
CA homeowners react with disbelief because, for decades, the opposite was true. They were told, "If you move, your property taxes will go way up." For many Californians, that was accurate before Proposition 19 expanded the transfer rules.
Here are the biggest reasons people don't believe it:
* It sounds too good to be true. Someone paying taxes based on a home they bought in 1995 may be paying a fraction of what they'd pay if they bought today. The idea that they can take that tax base with them feels unbelievable.
* They're remembering the old law. Before Proposition 19, you could only transfer your tax base under much more limited circumstances and only to participating counties. Many people—and even some professionals—still think those old rules apply.
* People misunderstand "transfer." They think you're literally paying the exact same property taxes forever. That's not how it works. You're transferring your base year value. If you buy a more expensive home, an adjustment is added for the price difference.
* Friends and neighbors repeat outdated information. You'll often hear, "My cousin moved and his taxes doubled." That may have happened before Proposition 19, or they may not have qualified or filed the claim correctly.
* They've heard horror stories about reassessment. California homeowners know buying a new home usually triggers reassessment, so it's hard to believe there's an exception.
👋Hi, I’m Shelley, and I’m a licensed California real estate agent and Realtor who sells in Tracy CA, Mountain House, CA and the surrounding cities with a focus on single story homes in and outside of active adult 55+ communities…. so if you’re looking to move out of a two-story and downsize into a single story then I’m your go-to.
Shelley Puentes
California Advantage Real Estate #01395691
Active Adult 55+ Real Estate Specialist
Tracy, California
Realtor®, RENE, PSA, ePRO, SRES®