09/15/2026
A Mesa couple purchased their home in 2014 next to a vacant lot. They said they relied on the neighboring lot’s designated “building envelope”—the area where construction was permitted—and later made substantial backyard improvements expecting a future home to stay within that area.
In 2023, a new owner purchased the vacant lot. The following year, the owner obtained approval from both the HOA and the City of Mesa to move the building envelope uphill, improving the view for the proposed home.
The couple sued to stop construction. They alleged the planned home would obstruct their views, reduce their privacy, and decrease their property’s value by $300,000.
On August 28, 2026, the Arizona Court of Appeals affirmed dismissal of their private nuisance claim. The court held that the anticipated loss of views and privacy, under these circumstances, did not establish an actionable nuisance. Another key detail: the HOA’s governing documents allowed building envelopes to be modified, so the original location was not guaranteed to remain unchanged.
When a view is part of what you’re paying for, investigate what legally protects it. Review recorded restrictions, easements, HOA rules, and neighboring development approvals—including the process for changing them.
The view you fall in love with today may depend on property you don’t own.
This post is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice.
Eric Thomae, REALTOR®/Attorney
Rockpath Group | Realty Executives Arizona Territory
📞 (520) 900-9038
📧 [email protected]
🌐 rockpathgroup.com
The Right Path Home