06/05/2026
The long-awaited expansion is officially complete as the East End’s premiere gourmet grocer opens its doors to the public. Westhampton Beach residents can now shop the highly anticipated Citarella Gourmet Market, located at 141 Montauk Highway. The landmark property, which previously housed the beloved Irish pub The Claddagh, has been completely transformed into a high-end culinary destination. This grand opening marks the brand’s fourth specialty market across the South Fork, joining established outposts in East Hampton, Bridgehampton, and Southampton.
Owner Joe Gurrera noted that for years, neighborhood residents had requested a location closer to home, and he expressed enthusiasm about joining the community and sharing a dedication to excellent food and genuine quality.
The arrival of the new market brings more than a century of fine food heritage to the area. Originally established by Mike Citarella on Manhattan’s Upper West Side in 1912, the business underwent a massive modern evolution after it was acquired in 1985 by Gurrera, a seasoned Fulton Street fishmonger. West End shoppers now have full access to Citarella’s signature premium offerings, ranging from pristine seafood and hand-cut prime beef to fresh bread, chef-prepared foods, freshly baked desserts, and farm-fresh local and organic produce.
Alongside the classic mainstays, visitors will discover a few brand-new creations exclusive to the Westhampton Beach location, including a custom Westhampton tote bag to carry purchases home. To accommodate local schedules, the new market operates seven days a week from 6:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m.
Beyond providing top-tier grocery convenience, the family-run enterprise remains deeply committed to its role as a local community partner. The new Westhampton Beach market continues the corporate tradition of actively supporting regional supply chains, working closely alongside local commercial fishermen, farmers, and florists.
🔗 https://patch.com/new-york/westhampton-hamptonbays/citarella-readying-open-doors-westhampton-beach