Sara Faye Nicholas, PA Realtor

Call Directions Website Contact the business

Sara Faye Nicholas, PA Realtor I sell homes in all of Central Florida for the most amount of money in the least amount of days possible on the market. www.Sarasellsfloridahomes.com

Who is Sara Faye Nicholas, PA

Recognized by BestAgents.us as a 2023 Top Agent.

2024 Top Agent Magazine Cover Feature Story

Finding joy in every listing, Sara brings a unique blend of expertise and enthusiasm to the real estate process, transforming goals into reality.

Sara is an esteemed Realtor with over two decades of expertise, proudly affiliated with Charles Rutenberg Realty in Winter Park, Florida. She is renowned for her deep market insight and steadfast dedication to client triumph, navigating buyers and sellers through seamless transactions.

Initially embarking on her real estate journey as an independent investor, Sara evolved into a committed advocate, aligning with Exit Realty in New Smyrna Beach and later leading an REO team. In 2015, she pursued an independent path, specializing in distressed property disposition and management across four to five counties in Central Florida.
With a focus on distressed properties and residential listings, Sara holds a proven track record of maximizing home sales in the shortest time possible on the market. Building relationships is at her core, emphasizing connections with clients, colleagues, and fellow professionals.

Her keen understanding of the local market empowers clients to make informed decisions, and her exceptional negotiation skills ensure successful deal navigation and favorable outcomes. A dedicated and strategic professional, Sara attributes her success to her extensive real estate knowledge, a proactive client approach, and a guiding motto of “prepare for the worst and hope for the best.” Her thriving business is rooted in a high client retention rate, highlighting trust and satisfaction as core principles.

Among her numerous accolades include the Unsung Hero Award in 2014, Top Listing Team, Highest Grossing Team Per Person Productivity, Top Closing Team, Top Sales Team, and Highest Grossing Team.
Beyond real estate, Sara actively contributes to her community, assisting lower-income families and engaging in charitable activities. She plans to expand her team’s success through innovative marketing techniques and enhanced collaboration to grow her current clientele.

In her personal life, Sara is an avid gardening enthusiast, holds a Black belt in Tae Kwon Do, and holds a deep connection to animals, particularly horses and dogs.

Whether you're a homeowner looking to sell, an investor seeking opportunities, or a buyer in search of your dream home, Sara’s decades of experience, passion, and proficiency make her the ideal partner for all your real estate endeavors.

🦃 Traditions are often the best part of the holiday season!What is your most beloved Thanksgiving tradition? Maybe it’s ...
11/13/2026

🦃 Traditions are often the best part of the holiday season!

What is your most beloved Thanksgiving tradition? Maybe it’s making a family recipe, watching the parade, a big family dinner, football after the meal, or gathering around the table to share what you’re thankful for.

🧡 What’s one Thanksgiving tradition your family wouldn’t skip?

Bathroom refresh on a budget? 🛁✨You do not need a full renovation to completely transform your bathroom. A few smart upd...
11/11/2026

Bathroom refresh on a budget? 🛁✨

You do not need a full renovation to completely transform your bathroom. A few smart updates can go a long way in making the space feel modern, clean, and refreshed.

🛠️ Keep the layout the same to avoid costly plumbing or electrical changes
💡 Update lighting fixtures for an instant modern upgrade
🎨 Paint cabinets or walls for one of the most affordable transformations
🛁 Refinish or reglaze instead of replacing your tub or shower when possible
🛒 Shop smart for fixtures and finishes by comparing options before buying
🧺 Swap soft decor items like towels, mats, and shower curtains for an easy refresh
🔧 DIY small updates where you can to help reduce labor costs

With the right mix of small changes, you can create a bathroom that feels brand new without the renovation price tag.

🏡 Touring multiple homes? Make sure you’re comparing more than just the asking price.When house hunting, it’s easy to fo...
11/09/2026

🏡 Touring multiple homes? Make sure you’re comparing more than just the asking price.

When house hunting, it’s easy to focus on standout features, but the details that affect your everyday life and long-term budget matter just as much.

💰 Monthly payment: Consider the full cost of ownership, including taxes, insurance, and potential HOA fees.

🛠️ Condition: Look at the home's overall upkeep, age of major systems, and any repairs that may be needed.

📍 Location: Compare commute times, nearby amenities, neighborhood features, and convenience.

✨ Updates: Consider which improvements have already been made and what you may want to change yourself.

🏡 Overall value: Weigh the price, features, condition, and location against your needs and priorities.

The right comparison can help you look beyond first impressions and make a decision that feels right for your budget and lifestyle.

Ready to find a home that fits your goals? Let’s connect and make a plan for your search.

Understanding what determines your borrowing capacity can help you prepare and sometimes increase how much you can borro...
11/06/2026

Understanding what determines your borrowing capacity can help you prepare and sometimes increase how much you can borrow. 🏦💰

Key factors that influence your borrowing power:

💼 Income and employment - stability and consistency matter
💳 Existing debts - Credit cards, car loans, and other repayments impact your overall borrowing ability
📊 Credit history - missed payments and defaults can affect your result
🧾 Living expenses - lenders assess your ongoing financial commitments
💰 Deposit size - a larger deposit can reduce risk and strengthen your application
🏠 Loan type and term - what you apply for also affects the assessment

The good news? Many of these areas can often be improved with preparation and the right guidance before applying!

📣 PRICE REDUCED — NOW $152,000📍 4179 Spitfire Avenue, Kissimmee, FL 34741🛏 2 Bedrooms | 🛁 2 Bathrooms📐 930 Sq. Ft. | Tow...
11/05/2026

📣 PRICE REDUCED — NOW $152,000

📍 4179 Spitfire Avenue, Kissimmee, FL 34741
🛏 2 Bedrooms | 🛁 2 Bathrooms
📐 930 Sq. Ft. | Townhouse

Contact me for property details or to schedule a showing.

Sara Faye Nicholas, PA, REALTOR®
Charles Rutenberg Realty
📲 407-864-1745
📧 [email protected]

💔 Don’t let these common mistakes cost you your dream home:1️⃣ Skipping pre-approval2️⃣ Forgetting additional costs like...
11/04/2026

💔 Don’t let these common mistakes cost you your dream home:

1️⃣ Skipping pre-approval
2️⃣ Forgetting additional costs like closing fees, taxes, and insurance
3️⃣ Making big purchases before closing (don’t mess with your credit!)
4️⃣ Overlooking first-time homebuyer programs
5️⃣ Underestimating the value of a great agent

These are easy to avoid, but so many buyers fall into these traps. 😭

You, however, are now one step ahead! Want more tips to navigate the homebuying process like a pro? Let’s connect, send a DM, and let’s chat! 💌

🏡 If you could add 200 square feet to your home, where would it go?A bigger kitchen? A dedicated home office? More close...
11/02/2026

🏡 If you could add 200 square feet to your home, where would it go?

A bigger kitchen? A dedicated home office? More closet space? A guest room? Or maybe an outdoor living area that gives you more room to actually enjoy your home.

Sometimes a little extra space in the right place can make a bigger difference than simply having a larger home.

If your next home could give you those extra 200 square feet, what would you want it to add?

Buying a home for the first time can feel overwhelming, but the process is more structured than it may seem. 🏡🔑Here’s a ...
10/30/2026

Buying a home for the first time can feel overwhelming, but the process is more structured than it may seem. 🏡🔑

Here’s a simplified roadmap:

1️⃣ Get pre-approved: Understand your budget and financing options before you start seriously searching.
2️⃣ Search strategically: Focus on the location, features, and lifestyle priorities that matter most to you.
3️⃣ Make an informed offer: Consider the home’s value, local market conditions, financing, contingencies, and other terms, not just the asking price.
4️⃣ Review the home and paperwork: Complete a home inspection where applicable, review disclosures and important documents, confirm financing and insurance requirements, and address any conditions before moving forward.
5️⃣ Close on the home: Complete your final walkthrough, sign the necessary documents, and receive the keys once the transaction is officially closed.

Every purchase is different, and having the right guidance is crucial.

Ready to take the first step toward homeownership? Let's connect and build a plan for your purchase from start to finish!

What better time than now to fall in love with your neighborhood?Here are some fun ways to connect with new people and d...
10/28/2026

What better time than now to fall in love with your neighborhood?

Here are some fun ways to connect with new people and discover hidden gems:

🚶‍♂️ Take walks to meet your neighbors
🌳 Visit local parks or join recreation clubs
📚 Join a book club at your community library
☕ Work from cozy local coffee shops

And remember, whatever you do, do it with a smile! 😊

A dedicated reading corner can make a home feel a little more personal. 📚Maybe it’s a comfy window seat, built-in shelve...
10/26/2026

A dedicated reading corner can make a home feel a little more personal. 📚

Maybe it’s a comfy window seat, built-in shelves with warm lighting, or a quiet nook with garden views and soft, neutral finishes. The right setup can turn an overlooked corner into the beloved spot in the house.

Which style would make your wish list?

Address

631 S. Orlando Avenue , Ste 200
Winter Park, FL
32789

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 5pm
Tuesday 9am - 5pm
Wednesday 9am - 5pm
Thursday 9am - 5pm
Friday 9am - 5pm
Saturday 9am - 5pm

Telephone

+14078641745

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Sara Faye Nicholas, PA Realtor posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Sara Faye Nicholas, PA Realtor:

Shortcuts

Share

Category

Nearby realtors & realty services