04/15/2026
Sometimes City Hall gets it wrong. And sometimes the development community gets it wrong. As Yellowknife City Council prepares to review the draft Community Plan today at noon, I want to share a couple of anecdotes that will hopefully remind Council to try to steer the ship without oversteering.
Developers and builders (and real estate brokers...) often complain that the City is trying to do to much - trying to socially engineer our city in ways that make development too challenging. They need to simply go away, and let the market dictate what gets built. But we've seen, right here in our city, what happens when developers are left to their own devices.
I'll cite one specific piece of land, because it has been the site of both not enough and too much meddling by City Hall. What is now home to the Greenstone Building on Yellowknife's main street, Franklin Avenue, used to be home to a sprawling, hideous, windowless department store - the Hudson's Bay and later Canadian Tire building. Legend has it, it was a huge collection of ATCO-type trailers, stitched together into what can only be described as a one-storey precursor to big box stores, with pale yellow stucco exterior, minus the high ceiling and windows.
I used to own coffee shops on either side of it, and as I began to take an interest in downtown revitalization, the Canadian Tire building became for me a symbol of development run amok. Long-time residents may recall that a local artist, Dawn Oman, was commissioned to paint a mural on the main street facade in an attempt to make it less hideous. Images of this seem to have been scrubbed from the internet, which is perhaps understandable.
Then in about 2003 an urbanists' miracle happened. The federal government announced that it had bought the old Canadian Tire and planned to build a shiny new LEED Gold "legacy" office building in its place - the Greenstone Building.
The main-street-facing side of the building was to include a spacious park with landscaping and benches, an oasis of public space to be enjoyed by all as they make their way down main street. But then City Hall got involved. The main-street-facing side was also designed with a dramatic curved facade, complete with solar panels. But the solar panels were designed to face...westward. Well, everybody knows that's no way to maximize solar exposure, so City Hall and City Council insisted that the building be flipped around so that the panels would face south. And that's why the Greenstone Building will forever have its back to our main street, and a lovely public park completely hidden from view. Many people don't even know the park exists.
All this to say, somewhere in the middle, between the planners and Council and the developers, is the right approach. Here's hoping City Council takes the time to run the draft Community Plan by Yellowknife's shrinking development community to see if it strikes the right balance.
Photo credit: Kyle Thomas