Michelle Wininger, Realtor

Call Directions Website Contact the business

Michelle Wininger, Realtor Luxury waterfront expertise across two coastlines.
CT | William Pitt Sotheby’s Int’l Realty & The Florida Keys | Elevating how you buy, sell, live.

It's not about selling real estate, it's about helping people. We believe that everyone deserves the exceptional, regardless of price and that every home is a masterpiece. It is truly my pleasure to walk with you throughout the journey of purchasing and selling your first or next home. Remember, with my global outreach, I am able to connect you with a great agent anywhere in the world. Where your next adventure takes you, I welcome to the opportunity to be a trusted advisor along the way.

11/19/2026

The Florida Keys are calling, and your future self knows it.
If you’ve been coming down here for years, you already know that feeling—already missing it before you even pack your bags to head home.

It’s easy to keep putting off the idea of buying a place of your own, waiting for the timing to feel just right.
Sometimes, the best first step is simply starting to explore what’s possible.

I love helping out-of-state buyers find their second homes and weekend retreats across the Keys.

Whether it’s FaceTime walkthroughs, comparing the different islands, or talking through boat dockage and local rental guidelines, I’m here to make the process feel easy—even from a thousand miles away.

The people spending this coming winter on their own lanai usually start with a simple, no-pressure conversation.
Whenever you’re ready to start dreaming a little closer to reality, let’s connect.

I’d love to be your personal connection to the FL Keys.

Michelle Wininger, Advisor
Ocean Sotheby’s Int’l Realty
MichelleWininger.com

11/17/2026

True Keys lifestyle, zero heavy lifting.

Two new residences are hitting the beachfront community of Sea Isle in Key Colony Beach very soon.

Step onto the sand, lock the door when you fly home, and hold a turnkey island asset in the heart of the Middle Keys.

DM me “SEA ISLE” for private pre-market details.

Your Personal Connection to Key Colony Beach.

Michelle Wininger, Advisor
Ocean Sotheby’s Int’l Realty
MichelleWininger.com

11/12/2026

Two distinct markets. One well-connected advisor.
Bridging the Connecticut shoreline with William Pitt Sotheby’s Int’l Realty and the Middle Keys with Ocean Sotheby’s Int’l Realty.

If you’ve been watching single-family waterfront real estate across the Middle Keys in 2026, here is how our three core markets compare:

📍 Marathon
• 97 Single-Family Waterfront Sales
• $1,999,000 Median List | $1,750,000 Median Sale (94.55% List-to-Sale)

• The Takeaway: With the most inventory on the market, Marathon offers the widest selection and strongest entry point for waterfront buyers.

📍 Key Colony Beach
• 24 Single-Family Waterfront Sales
• $2,712,000 Median List | $2,450,000 Median Sale (95.36% List-to-Sale)

• The Takeaway: Buyers pay a premium for this tight-knit island community—known for 7-day vacation rentals, golf, pickleball courts, and walkable waterfront dining.

📍 Duck Key
• 8 Single-Family Waterfront Sales
• $2,695,500 Median List | $2,387,500 Median Sale (91.5% List-to-Sale)

• The Takeaway: An exclusive enclave with beautiful oceanfront properties where tight supply and strong demand continue to drive the highest price points.
What does this mean for your move?

Market statistics are a great starting point, but every property—and every timeline—is unique.

If you’re considering a purchase or a sale and want help interpreting how this data applies to your specific situation, I’d be happy to take a look and guide you through your options.

Send me a DM or reach out directly.
Your personal connection to the Middle Keys.

Michelle Wininger, Advisor
Ocean & William Pitt Sotheby’s Int’l Realty

MiddleKeysRealEstate DuckKey KeyColonyBeach MarathonFL ConnecticutToFlorida WaterfrontLivin

Sotheby’s International Realty continues to make headlines across the globe. Swipe to see our top press highlights from ...
11/06/2026

Sotheby’s International Realty continues to make headlines across the globe. Swipe to see our top press highlights from October.

📍 New to Market 📍 Take a look at this fantastic new property that just hit the market located at 55-69 Sawmill Road in B...
10/18/2026

📍 New to Market 📍 Take a look at this fantastic new property that just hit the market located at 55-69 Sawmill Road in Branford. Reach out here or at 860.707.5389 for more information!

Listed by Michelle Wininger

Branford treasure returns to the market. Once a 19th-century sawmill, this storybook stone residence carries a piece of Connecticut's heritage into an extraordinary setting: a private waterfall, tidal creek on two acres. Transformed into a home in 1939 with the original mill structure thoughtfull...

📍 New to Market 📍 Take a look at this fantastic new property that just hit the market located at 66 High Street  #4 in G...
10/13/2026

📍 New to Market 📍 Take a look at this fantastic new property that just hit the market located at 66 High Street #4 in Guilford. Reach out here or at 860.707.5389 for more information!

Listed by Janet Cronin-Rumanoff

Just steps from Guilford's historic town green, vibrant boutiques, and gourmet dining-and a short stroll to the town marina and train station-The Residences at 66 High Street offers an extraordinary blend of historic character & cosmopolitan luxury in the award-winning complex. Step inside this s...

The Third Quarter 2026 Market Watch has arrived.Take a closer look at where the market stands and where it’s headed.Read...
10/08/2026

The Third Quarter 2026 Market Watch has arrived.
Take a closer look at where the market stands and where it’s headed.

Read more at williampitt.com

Sotheby’s International Realty continues to make headlines across the globe. Swipe to see our top press highlights from ...
10/02/2026

Sotheby’s International Realty continues to make headlines across the globe. Swipe to see our top press highlights from September.

📍 New to Market 📍 Take a look at this fantastic new property that just hit the market located at 40 Brookhills Road in B...
09/20/2026

📍 New to Market 📍 Take a look at this fantastic new property that just hit the market located at 40 Brookhills Road in Branford. Reach out here or at 860.707.5389 for more information!

Listed by Mark McElrath

More than a residence, this is a world unto itself. Encompassing 6.57 acres, this singular Branford estate offers the space to shape an extraordinary lifestyle. Zoning allows for up to six horses, with a four-stall barn offering a loft, lower level ideal for a w**e cellar, and versatility for thr...

Address

Branford, CT

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Michelle Wininger, Realtor posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Michelle Wininger, Realtor:

Shortcuts

Share

Category