08/21/2026
Here's a common trick tenants used after the pandemic.
And how landlords who didn't watch out paid for it.
The fixed-rate "right to renew."
A right to extend the lease at a pre-set rate (usually below market).
The tenant decides whether the lease continues.
The landlord doesn't get to renegotiate.
When I started in July 2023, my first deals were office leases.
On my first building, I was signing 3 and 5 year leases at $20/SF.
The owner showed me his pre-pandemic leases — $23-24/SF, one at $27.
That building rebounded. In January 2026, we signed a lease at $24.50/SF. A 22.5% increase.
If the $20 leases had renewal rights, the landlord wouldn’t have gotten $24.50 on the renewal.
Back in COVID, many landlords gave tenants rights to renew to “close the deal.”
Those renewal rights married buildings to long-term rents below market.
No matter how desperate I was, I always killed the right to renew.
Fixed-rate or not, I don't like giving tenants one-sided control over a landlord's space.
You might have a dog of a space. The tenant might beat you up on rent or term.
Fine. But never give them a right to renew.
If the market gets better or you renovate the building, you get 0 for your work.
I pulled every lease I've brokered since July 2023. Only 2.9% include a right to renew.
They're a tool for exceptional circumstances. Not something to include blindly.