2026-10-05
The Bank of Canada Just Admitted It Can't Fix Housing Affordability
On the first day of October, in front of a business audience in Victoria, the Bank of Canada's second-in-command stood up and said something refreshingly plain: the Bank cannot fix housing affordability, and Canadians should stop expecting it to. Senior Deputy Governor Carolyn Rogers called the policy interest rate "a blunt tool" that sets one price for borrowing across the entire economy, and pointed out that no setting on that dial builds a single home (Bank of Canada, "Canada's Housing Affordability Dilemma", October 1, 2026).
I have been waiting years for a senior official to say this in public, because I hear the opposite assumption at kitchen tables every month. Buyers tell me they are holding off until the Bank sorts things out. Sellers price a house on the theory that the next cut will send buyers stampeding back. Rogers spent half an hour explaining why both camps are leaning on a rescue that is not coming.
One rate, two bad options
The heart of her speech was a bind the Bank cannot get out of. Cut rates to help buyers and prices tend to rise, which takes the help back. Raise rates to cool prices and you squeeze every borrower and business in the country to get at one sector. And a deliberate attempt to push house prices down would land on household wealth in a way no central bank can be casual about, because roughly half of all bank lending in Canada is tied to residential real estate (BNN Bloomberg, October 1, 2026). Whatever your politics, that is the arithmetic the Bank is staring at.
She added a number I found sobering. In 2000, Canada put 4.3 per cent of its GDP into residential investment and 8.3 per cent into business investment - the machinery and technology that make wages grow. Those two numbers have since traded places (The Globe and Mail, October 1, 2026). We have spent a generation pouring our savings into each other's houses, and Rogers was direct about this sitting at the heart of the country's productivity problem. She also pushed back on the idea that cheap pandemic money alone caused the boom, noting that immigration, building constraints and speculation all fed the roughly 50 per cent jump in average prices over two years.
So where does help actually come from? Her list was short and unglamorous: more supply through zoning and planning reform, infrastructure to serve it, and restraint about policies that add demand to markets that cannot build fast enough. Every item on that list lives with provinces and municipalities, not with the Bank. For those of us in Markham, the decisions that will move affordability are the ones I wrote about before the municipal election: where the next 44,000 homes go, and what happens to the fees and timelines that shape what builders can actually deliver.
Planning around a Bank that will not rescue you
First, make your plans at today's rates, not tomorrow's rumoured ones. The Bank held its policy rate at 2.25 per cent on September 2, the seventh straight hold, and the next decision comes October 28 (Bank of Canada). Cuts may come eventually. But Rogers has now said directly that restoring affordability is not the Bank's project, so any cut will be about inflation and the broader economy, and the bond market that actually prices fixed mortgages spent September pushing those rates up, not down. If the math on a purchase or a renewal works at current rates, it works. If it only works after an imagined rescue, it does not work, and no amount of waiting changes that.
Second, if you are selling this fall, build your price on the last sixty days of comparable sales rather than on a theory about spring. I have watched sellers sit on the market since Labour Day waiting for a rate story to save an ambitious list price. The official most responsible for that story just told everyone, politely and in public, to stop waiting. Price to the market in front of you, present the home properly, and let the house compete on its merits, because the referee has confirmed she is not coming off the sidelines.