Bartlett Benner Realty

Bartlett Benner Realty Bartlett Benner Realty is a major real estate firm serving Fairfield and surrounding counties Looking to sell your house? Contact us to start the process.

Since 1991, Barlett Benner Realty has bought and sold real estate in Lancaster, OH, and surrounding areas. At our independent real estate agency in Lancaster, OH, we offer expertise in single-family, multi-family, land, farms, commercial, industrial, and auction services. Through our knowledge and experience, we ensure our clients receive the advice they need to make informed decisions. When you n

eed the best advice to help you achieve your real estate goals, then you'll want to contact any of our realtors today to schedule an appointment. Our real estate agents can help you tailor a home search to exactly what you are looking for. Our agency broker, Gary Bartlett, can help!

06/03/2026

New Listing by Agent Nic Bartlett

15005 Jack Run Rd. Rockbridge, OH 43149

Fantastic Hocking Hills Investment & Recreational Opportunity! Discover 85 acres of scenic land in the heart of Hocking Hills, offering abundant wildlife, privacy, and endless potential. The property features access from Jack Run Road via a shared driveway easement, along with approximately 200 feet of road frontage on Clapper Hollow Road. A rustic cabin provides the perfect secluded getaway and includes the benefit of free gas. Whether you're seeking a private recreational retreat, hunting property, or an income-producing investment, this property offers exceptional versatility. With ample room for expansion, the property is ideally suited for a short-term rental (STR) cabin development, allowing investors to capitalize on the area's strong tourism market. It also presents a unique opportunity for mixed-use ownership--enjoy your own private retreat while generating income from additional cabins. Conveniently located near State Route 180, Hocking Hills State Park, and many of the area's most popular attractions, outdoor adventures, restaurants, and amenities, this property combines seclusion with accessibility in one of Ohio's premier destination markets. Don't miss this rare opportunity to own a large acreage tract in Hocking Hills with recreational, residential, and investment potential.

Asking Price: $915,000

Nic Bartlett 614-530-1885

New Listing by Agent Nic Bartlett 15005 Jack Run Rd. Rockbridge, OH 43149Fantastic Hocking Hills Investment & Recreation...
06/03/2026

New Listing by Agent Nic Bartlett

15005 Jack Run Rd. Rockbridge, OH 43149

Fantastic Hocking Hills Investment & Recreational Opportunity! Discover 85 acres of scenic land in the heart of Hocking Hills, offering abundant wildlife, privacy, and endless potential. The property features access from Jack Run Road via a shared driveway easement, along with approximately 200 feet of road frontage on Clapper Hollow Road. A rustic cabin provides the perfect secluded getaway and includes the benefit of free gas. Whether you're seeking a private recreational retreat, hunting property, or an income-producing investment, this property offers exceptional versatility. With ample room for expansion, the property is ideally suited for a short-term rental (STR) cabin development, allowing investors to capitalize on the area's strong tourism market. It also presents a unique opportunity for mixed-use ownership--enjoy your own private retreat while generating income from additional cabins. Conveniently located near State Route 180, Hocking Hills State Park, and many of the area's most popular attractions, outdoor adventures, restaurants, and amenities, this property combines seclusion with accessibility in one of Ohio's premier destination markets. Don't miss this rare opportunity to own a large acreage tract in Hocking Hills with recreational, residential, and investment potential.

Asking Price: $915,000

Nic Bartlett 614-530-1885

New Listing by Broker/Agent Gary Bartlett & Agent Nic Bartlett432 S Ewing Street, Lancaster, OH 43130This 5.75-acre prop...
06/02/2026

New Listing by Broker/Agent Gary Bartlett & Agent Nic Bartlett

432 S Ewing Street, Lancaster, OH 43130

This 5.75-acre property is zoned Advanced Manufacturing and offers a versatile investment or owner-user opportunity. Improvements include a 1,344 sq. ft. office building and four pole buildings totaling approximately 16,112 sq. ft., measuring 3,200 sq. ft., 3,520 sq. ft., 3,840 sq. ft., and 5,552 sq. ft. Each building is equipped with office space and restrooms, features drive-through overhead doors, and three of the buildings include loading docks. Constructed between 1993 and 1998, the property has been well maintained and includes partial paving throughout the site. All buildings are currently leased on a month-to-month basis to long-term tenants, providing immediate income while allowing flexibility for future use. With ample excess land available for additional industrial buildings, storage units, outdoor storage, or future expansion, this property offers significant upside potential. Conveniently zoned for Advanced Manufacturing, the site is well suited for a variety of industrial, warehouse, contractor, or investment applications. Listing agent has a financial affiliation with the property.

Asking Price- $975,000

Gary Bartlett 614-371-5309

Nic Bartlett 614-530-1885

Last minute booking special! 🚨The Wayne National Forest OHV trails are OPEN! 🏍️🌲Grab your crew and come enjoy the perfec...
05/29/2026

Last minute booking special! 🚨
The Wayne National Forest OHV trails are OPEN! 🏍️🌲
Grab your crew and come enjoy the perfect weekend getaway — riding, camping, relaxing, and making memories outdoors 😎🏕️🔥
Whether you’re hitting the trails all day or unwinding by the fire at night, now’s the time to book your stay!
Message us for availability and rates before the weekend fills up! 👊

Discover the perfect base for outdoor adventure at Trackside Haven.

New Listing! Give us a call today while this is still available!
05/22/2026

New Listing! Give us a call today while this is still available!

Listed for sale at $429977. Nestled on 2 beautiful acres, this charming 3 bedroom, 2.5 bath home offers the perfect blend of privacy, space, and fun...

Price drop!Turn-Key Cabin Business & Real Estate | Premier Ohio Retreat Collection Rare opportunity to acquire a fully-o...
05/22/2026

Price drop!

Turn-Key Cabin Business & Real Estate | Premier Ohio Retreat Collection Rare opportunity to acquire a fully-operational luxury cabin business, including two high-end short-term rental cabins, established brand, booking platforms, guest pipeline, furnishings, and all business assets. This proven hospitality operation offers immediate cash flow and a trusted reputation in Ohio's thriving cabin rental market. Set on a beautiful private parcel, each cabin was professionally designed with upscale finishes, vaulted ceilings, curated décor, full kitchens, private outdoor entertainment areas, and wooded views that deliver the true getaway experience guests demand. The property has been meticulously maintained and thoughtfully developed for repeat guests and premium nightly rates. Highlights: Two modern, custom-built cabins on one parcel Well-established STR brand + digital presence Fully furnished + equipped — truly turnkey Strong rental history + documented performance Future reservations convey Proven systems, processes, and operating model in place Expansion potential on site (verify with county) This is more than real estate — it's a functioning hospitality business with a loyal guest base, refined marketing systems, and exceptional reputation. Step into a profitable operation on day one and continue to scale in one of Ohio's most desirable getaway markets.

Listed for sale at $1490000. Turn-Key Cabin Business & Real Estate | Premier Ohio Retreat Collection Rare opportunity to acquire a fully-operational ...

Investment Opportunity in Athens still available!Give us a call today! 740-654-1500
05/22/2026

Investment Opportunity in Athens still available!

Give us a call today! 740-654-1500

Listed for sale at $78900. Excellent investment opportunity in University Commons near Ohio University. This upper-level condo is tenant occupied w...

New Listing!Welcome to this beautifully updated home in a highly desirable subdivision, conveniently located near the el...
05/22/2026

New Listing!

Welcome to this beautifully updated home in a highly desirable subdivision, conveniently located near the elementary school and just minutes from Route 33 -- offering quick access while still enjoying the peace and quiet outside of the busy town atmosphere. Since 2020, this home has seen extensive updates throughout. Enjoy the open-concept layout created by removing two walls, giving the main living space a bright, spacious feel perfect for entertaining and everyday living. The custom kitchen features quality cabinetry with soft-close drawers and doors, a large kitchen island, granite countertops, and newer LG appliances throughout the kitchen. Additional improvements include new flooring, new carpet throughout, updated tile in the bathrooms, downstairs landing, and bar area, new bathroom vanities, new base trim and door casing throughout, a new Trex deck, updated fireplace mantle, fresh paint throughout the entire home, and a finished downstairs bathroom with drop ceiling installation. The home also offers the rare bonus of both gas and wood-burning fireplaces, adding warmth and character for every season. Enjoy the convenience of county water and sewer service while living in a quiet neighborhood setting. This move-in-ready property combines modern updates, functional living space, and a prime location all in one package.

Listed for sale at $389900. Welcome to this beautifully updated home in a highly desirable subdivision, conveniently located near the elementary sch...

New Listing!Nestled in the heart of Hocking Hills, this historic farmhouse offers a rare combination of timeless charm, ...
05/22/2026

New Listing!

Nestled in the heart of Hocking Hills, this historic farmhouse offers a rare combination of timeless charm, breathtaking scenery, and proven Airbnb potential. A version of the Kreashbaum farmhouse has stood on this land since 1797, creating a truly unique opportunity to own a piece of local history while enjoying modern updates and strong investment appeal. Conveniently located within 15 minutes of many of Hocking County's most popular attractions, parks, hiking trails, and recreational destinations, this property is perfectly positioned for full-time living, a weekend retreat, or an income-producing short-term rental. Bordering State of Ohio forest land, the property is surrounded by the natural beauty that draws visitors to the Hocking Hills region year after year. Stunning panoramic views can be enjoyed from the home, hot tub, and fire ring both day and night. Wildlife is abundant, including local and migrating birds along with wild turkey frequently visible from the property.
The barn offers electric service and ample storage space, while the garden shed includes additional storage and a bicycle shelter for guests. Extensive updates since 2023 provide peace of mind, including new HVAC, roof, siding, electric, plumbing, drilled well producing 10+ GPM, propane tank, redesigned patio and hot tub area, backup generator, improved garden shed and bicycle shelter, barn roof replacement, and McBride water conditioning and UV purification systems. Whether you're searching for a peaceful getaway, a turn-key Airbnb opportunity, or a property rich with history and natural beauty, this farmhouse delivers exceptional value at a reasonable price point with strong short-term rental appeal.

Listed for sale at $474900. Nestled in the heart of Hocking Hills, this historic farmhouse offers a rare combination of timeless charm, breathtaking...

05/17/2026

Address

2751 W Fair Avenue
Lancaster, OH
43130

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 5pm
Tuesday 9am - 5pm
Wednesday 9am - 5pm
Thursday 9am - 5pm
Friday 9am - 5pm

Telephone

+17406541500

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Bartlett Benner Realty posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Bartlett Benner Realty:

Share