Bartlett Benner Realty

Call Directions Website Contact the business

Bartlett Benner Realty Bartlett Benner Realty is a leading real estate firm serving Central and Southeast Ohio. Looking to sell your house? Our agency broker, Gary Bartlett, can help!

Independently owned and family-operated since 1991, the company is committed to providing personalized service and local expertise. Since 1991, Barlett Benner Realty has bought and sold real estate in Lancaster, OH, and surrounding areas. At our independent real estate agency in Lancaster, OH, we offer expertise in single-family, multi-family, land, farms, commercial, industrial, and auction services. Through our knowledge and experience, we ensure our clients receive the advice they need to make informed decisions. When you need the best advice to help you achieve your real estate goals, then you'll want to contact any of our realtors today to schedule an appointment. Our real estate agents can help you tailor a home search to exactly what you are looking for. Contact us to start the process.

That went fast! In contract!
10/22/2026

That went fast! In contract!

Listed for sale at $279900. Brand-new construction offering the perfect blend of comfort, privacy, and peaceful surroundings! This beautiful 2-bedro...

Listing presented by Tony Coakley
10/22/2026

Listing presented by Tony Coakley

Listed for sale at $354900. Tucked away at the end of a quiet, beautiful cul-de-sac, this move-in-ready home offers a peaceful setting along with ex...

Commercial Property For Lease Presented by Agent Nic Bartlett 614-530-1885Welcome to The Hartman Building, located at 38...
10/22/2026

Commercial Property For Lease
Presented by Agent Nic Bartlett 614-530-1885

Welcome to The Hartman Building, located at 38 W. Waterloo Street in the heart of historic downtown Canal Wi******er, Ohio! This is an exceptional opportunity to bring your business vision to life in one of Central Ohio's most charming downtown districts. Offering over 10,000 square feet (+/-) of potential leasable space, the Hartman Building provides a versatile setting for a variety of business concepts, including restaurants, breweries, retail, office space, entertainment venues, and mixed-use developments. The property features large glass garage doors that provide abundant natural light, a spacious parking lot offering ample parking for customers and employees, and a unique historic character that is being brought back to life through ongoing renovations. The vision is to complement the charm and atmosphere that make downtown Canal Wi******er such a special destination. Located within the Old Town Commercial District, this property offers an opportunity to become part of the continued growth and revitalization of downtown. With its flexible space, convenient parking, prominent location, and historic appeal, the possibilities are extensive. Make your mark on downtown Canal Wi******er at the Hartman Building -- where historic character meets exciting new business opportunities!

New Listing by Agent Nic Bartlett 614-530-1885**Prime Commercial Lot - High-Traffic Location**Commercial lot convenientl...
10/08/2026

New Listing by Agent Nic Bartlett 614-530-1885

**Prime Commercial Lot - High-Traffic Location**

Commercial lot conveniently located on the corner of State Route 158, offering excellent visibility and exposure in a high-traffic area. The property is located in **Greenfield Township's B-1 Business District**, offering a variety of potential commercial uses. Buyer should verify zoning approval for their specific intended use with Greenfield Township.

The property is already equipped with **well and septic**. Septic tank size and system capacity are currently unknown and should be verified by the buyer.

With its prominent corner location, high traffic area, existing utilities, and B-1 Business zoning, this property offers an excellent opportunity for a variety of commercial ventures.

1.57 acres

Asking $225,000

Price drop! Now asking $799,000.Don’t miss out on this beautiful 85 acres in the Hocking Hills!
09/29/2026

Price drop! Now asking $799,000.

Don’t miss out on this beautiful 85 acres in the Hocking Hills!

Looking forward to seeing what the new owners are able to do with the space and what they bring to the Village of Lithop...
09/25/2026

Looking forward to seeing what the new owners are able to do with the space and what they bring to the Village of Lithopolis!

Contact Bartlett Benner Realty for all of your real estate needs — residential, commercial, land & farm, property management (residential, commercial & short-term rentals), commercial leasing, and more.

Bartlett Benner Realty — your local, family-owned, independent real estate firm serving Central and Southeastern Ohio.

New Listing!$359,900 -call to schedule a private showing
09/25/2026

New Listing!

$359,900 -call to schedule a private showing

Single family home for sale at 385 Kemper Avenue, Lancaster, OH. View photos, video tour & details.

New Listing presented by Nic Bartlett 614-530-1885Welcome to 385 Kemper Ave! This beautiful, well-maintained home has be...
09/24/2026

New Listing presented by Nic Bartlett 614-530-1885

Welcome to 385 Kemper Ave! This beautiful, well-maintained home has been lovingly cared for and has had only two owners throughout its history. Located in the highly desirable Kemper Subdivision, this home offers a convenient location in the heart of Lancaster, close to the hospital, downtown, shopping, dining, and all the amenities Lancaster has to offer.

Enjoy your morning coffee on the inviting front porch surrounded by mature trees, or host friends and family for a cookout on the back patio. Inside, the timeless kitchen provides a warm and welcoming space to start your day, while the home's overall character and charm make it a wonderful place to call home.

Homes in this sought-after neighborhood don't come available often. Don't miss your opportunity to become part of a community that neighbors are proud to call home!

Asking $359,900

New Listing!
09/03/2026

New Listing!

Listed for sale at $299900. Welcome to this beautifully maintained three-bedroom home situated on a corner lot with convenient ingress and egress. T...

New Listing!
09/03/2026

New Listing!

Address

2751 W Fair Avenue
Lancaster, OH
43130

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 5pm
Tuesday 9am - 5pm
Wednesday 9am - 5pm
Thursday 9am - 5pm
Friday 9am - 5pm

Telephone

+17406541500

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Bartlett Benner Realty posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Bartlett Benner Realty:

Shortcuts

Share