Tony Coakley, Bartlett Benner Realty

Call Directions Website Contact the business

Tony Coakley, Bartlett Benner Realty I am co-owner of Bartlett Benner Realty in Lancaster, Ohio.
I am your new build, land, remodel expert.

Congratulations to our buyer on securing this 2.58-acre property in Rushville! We are excited to see what the future hol...
10/31/2026

Congratulations to our buyer on securing this 2.58-acre property in Rushville! We are excited to see what the future holds for this land.

📞 Tony Coakley | Realtor, Brokerage Co-Owner
🏠 New Build, Land & Remodel Expert
🏡 Bartlett Benner Realty
📱 +1 (740) 215-6487
🌐 bartlettbennerrealty.com

🔨 INVESTOR SPECIAL UNDER $100K! 🔨Looking for your next project or a high-potential value-add property? Check out this 2-...
10/29/2026

🔨 INVESTOR SPECIAL UNDER $100K! 🔨

Looking for your next project or a high-potential value-add property?
Check out this 2-bedroom, 1-bath gem sitting on 1,548 sq ft of space in Crooksville, OH!

✨ Highlights: Price: $99,900 ($65/sq ft!)
Location: 12770 State Route 669 NW, Crooksville, OH 43731
Setting: Enjoy the peace of being on the outskirts of town while staying close to local schools!
Estimated Payment: ~$662/mo
Bring your vision, toolbelt, and creative ideas to complete this remodel and unlock serious equity! 🔑

📩 Interested? Message or call me today!
📞 Tony Coakley | Realtor, Brokerage Co-Owner
🏠 New Build, Land & Remodel Expert
🏡 Bartlett Benner Realty
📱 +1 (740) 215-6487
🌐 bartlettbennerrealty.com
Listing link: https://www.homes.com/property/12770-state-route-669-nw-crooksville-oh/vsp2f9kgvrfrs/

🏡 Move-in Ready in Logan — Now at an Even Better Price! 🏡Looking for peace, space, and modern updates without the work? ...
10/29/2026

🏡 Move-in Ready in Logan — Now at an Even Better Price! 🏡

Looking for peace, space, and modern updates without the work? This stunning 4-bedroom home is fully renovated and waiting for you!

From the custom kitchen with granite counters to the cozy finished basement bar area and brand-new Trex deck, every square foot has been thoughtfully updated since 2020!

📍 11795 James Dr, Logan, OH
💵 Now $344,900 ($10K Price Reduction!)

📞 Tony Coakley | Realtor, Brokerage Co-Owner
🏠 New Build, Land & Remodel Expert
🏡 Bartlett Benner Realty
📱 +1 (740) 215-6487
🌐 bartlettbennerrealty.com

Listing link: https://www.homes.com/property/11795-james-dr-logan-oh/lcq30t7hy3pfh/?fbclid=IwY2xjawVQKuFleHRuA2FlbQIxMQBwZG9mAXNydGMGYXBwX2lkEDIyMjAzOTE3ODgyMDA4OTIAAR8fRFh2krfnfUu8cygPRbkXOMdSn0PpuikMscbaWXxoUbVNnVVsSlcmvmuMkQ_aem_AqSnQTeRXZoqD2lXVder1A

Listed for sale at $354900. Tucked away at the end of a quiet, beautiful cul-de-sac, this move-in-ready home offers a peaceful setting along with ex...

10/23/2026

🏡 2336 W Fair Ave, Lancaster, OH 43130
🏷️ Offered at $285,900 (Price Cut $14K)

🛏️ 3 Bedrooms | 🛁 1 Bath | 📐 1,512 Sq Ft | 🌳 0.43 Acre Corner Lot

✨ Features include an eat-in kitchen, main-floor living room, ample closet space, multi-room flexible basement space, dual garage options, and recent energy efficiency updates throughout.

📩 Message us today for full details or to schedule a private tour!
📲 Tony Coakley: 740-215-6487
📲 Alayna Spiegel: 740-243-6305
🌐 www.bartlettbennerrealty.com
Listing link here: https://www.zillow.com/.../2336-W-Fair.../108638277_zpid/

10/21/2026
𝗣𝗥𝗜𝗖𝗘 𝗥𝗘𝗗𝗨𝗖𝗧𝗜𝗢𝗡: $𝟮𝟴𝟱,𝟵𝟬𝟬2336 W Fair Ave, Lancaster, OH 43130   Looking for space, functional design, and versatile stor...
10/21/2026

𝗣𝗥𝗜𝗖𝗘 𝗥𝗘𝗗𝗨𝗖𝗧𝗜𝗢𝗡: $𝟮𝟴𝟱,𝟵𝟬𝟬
2336 W Fair Ave, Lancaster, OH 43130
Looking for space, functional design, and versatile storage?
This 3-bed, 1-bath home in Lancaster is set on a 0.43-acre corner lot.

Highlights:
• Bright main level with eat-in kitchen and spacious living room
• Flexible basement layout with extra rooms and additional bathroom area
• Two garages including a basement-level garage/root cellar and upper attic storage
• Upgraded attic insulation and basement pipe wrapping completed within the past year.

For more information or to schedule a private showing, contact us today!
📲 Tony Coakley: 740-215-6487
📲 Alayna Spiegel: 740-243-6305
🌐 www.bartlettbennerrealty.com

Listing link here: https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/2336-W-Fair-Ave-Lancaster-OH-43130/108638277_zpid/

We have another home under contract! 496 Danbury Dr is one step closer to sold.Whether you are ready to put your home on...
10/18/2026

We have another home under contract! 496 Danbury Dr is one step closer to sold.

Whether you are ready to put your home on the market or start searching for your next place, we are here to help make it happen.

📞 Tony Coakley | Realtor, Brokerage Co-Owner
🏠 New Build, Land & Remodel Expert
🏡 Bartlett Benner Realty
📱 +1 (740) 215-6487
🌐 bartlettbennerrealty.com

Just Listed!35990 Greasy Ridge Road, Logan, OH 43138Offered at $289,900   Brand-new construction offering the perfect bl...
10/15/2026

Just Listed!
35990 Greasy Ridge Road, Logan, OH 43138
Offered at $289,900

Brand-new construction offering the perfect blend of comfort, privacy, and peaceful surroundings! This beautiful 2-bedroom, 2-bath home features a thoughtfully designed layout and scenic views that make it an ideal full-time residence, weekend getaway, or private retreat.

Key features include:
🛏️ 2 Bedrooms
🛁 2 Bathrooms
📐 820 Sq Ft
🔨 Brand-new construction
🌲 Peaceful settings perfect for relaxing and enjoying the outdoors

Whether you are looking for a place to call home, a second home near area attractions, or exploring the possibility of a short-term rental investment, this property offers plenty of possibilities. For more details or to get on the interest list before it hits the market, contact us today

When you list your home, you deserve an agent who goes above and beyond to protect your interests and deliver results. T...
10/13/2026

When you list your home, you deserve an agent who goes above and beyond to protect your interests and deliver results. Thank you, Robin, for these amazing 5 stars—it was a pleasure working with you!

📞 Tony Coakley | Realtor, Brokerage Co-Owner
🏠 New Build, Land & Remodel Expert
🏡 Bartlett Benner Realty
📱 +1 (740) 215-6487
🌐 bartlettbennerrealty.com

Coming soon in Logan!35990 Greasy Ridge Road, Logan, OH 43138Offered at $289,900   Brand-new construction offering the p...
10/09/2026

Coming soon in Logan!

35990 Greasy Ridge Road, Logan, OH 43138
Offered at $289,900

Brand-new construction offering the perfect blend of comfort, privacy, and peaceful surroundings! This beautiful 2-bedroom, 2-bath home features a thoughtfully designed layout and scenic views that make it an ideal full-time residence, weekend getaway, or private retreat.

Key features include:
🛏️ 2 Bedrooms
🛁 2 Bathrooms
📐 820 Sq Ft
🔨 Brand-new construction
🌲 Peaceful settings perfect for relaxing and enjoying the outdoors

Whether you are looking for a place to call home, a second home near area attractions, or exploring the possibility of a short-term rental investment, this property offers plenty of possibilities. For more details or to get on the interest list before it hits the market, contact us today!

Address

2751 W Fair Avenue
Lancaster, OH
43130

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Tony Coakley, Bartlett Benner Realty posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Tony Coakley, Bartlett Benner Realty:

Shortcuts

Share

Category

Nearby realtors & realty services