09/29/2026
In May 2025, SF selected CITY attorney Raju announced that his office would decline new clients one business day a week. Conveniently, the announcement was timed perfectly to coincide with City Hall's negotiations over his department's budget.
His budget wasn't cut that year. In fact, while other departments faced 15% cuts, the Public Defender's office received a $2.2 million increase.
Nonetheless, in October 2025, Raju doubled his refusal policy: his office would now decline new misdemeanor clients two business days a week. (He still rejected felony cases one day a week.)
It's a stunning thing. Imagine deciding to stop showing up for work every Monday and Wednesday. Now imagine announcing that work stoppage publicly to your company and all its customers. And then imagine using it to extort them for more money.
It’s crazy, but the consequences are real.
Between May to November 2025, the Public Defender's office refused 470 cases: 147 felonies and 323 misdemeanors. By the start of this year, it had refused over 250 felonies. In March, Raju said his office was still declining new clients one day a week. As recently as last month, defendants were left at arraignments without a lawyer because no public defender was available to take their case.
When a defendant has no lawyer, the case goes to the back of the queue and the court system is forced into triage.
In October 2025, San Francisco Superior Court began releasing some jailed pretrial defendants because no public defender was willing to represent them. The court warned that if this continued, entire cases would have to be dismissed, and the accused would walk free without a trial.
(By the way, this is what happened in Oregon, where the state Supreme Court has ruled that as many as 1,400 criminal cases could be dismissed because defendants could not secure a lawyer.)
The San Francisco Bar Association tried to fill the gap. In January, it was reported that more than 50 private lawyers had taken on 600 to 800 additional defense cases. But the Bar Association quickly ran out of bandwidth and had to stop, with a representative calling the effort "completely unsustainable."
For the public, the impact is clear. The Public Defender's refusal to do his job has created a serious public safety hazard. Pretrial defendants are walking free without trials or hearings, crimes go unresolved, and victims are denied justice.
Taxpayers are also paying twice for public defense: once to fund the Public Defender's office, and again to pay private attorneys to represent the defendants the Public Defender turns away.
Raju's decision is also deeply unfair, even abusive, to defendants. Dozens have been left to linger in the system for weeks waiting for an attorney.
This summer, one defendant arrived on time for his arraignment but was never assigned a lawyer. He waited so long that he eventually left, and as a result was then issued a bench warrant and arrested again for missing his hearing. Whether or not he was guilty of the original charge, it's hard to justify arresting someone a second time for showing up on time to a hearing where he was never going to get a lawyer.
The most profound damage is to the norms and trust that hold our criminal courts together. At a time when civic institutions everywhere are threatened by gamesmanship, Raju's actions stand out for being so local and so brazen.
His conduct has been so egregious that Superior Court Judge Harry Dorfman held him in contempt of court and fined him $26,000: $1,000 for each of the 26 times Raju defied a court order to represent a defendant. Judge Dorfman concluded that the office had lawyers available to handle the felony cases it was refusing, and was therefore willfully disobeying the court.
Raju has appealed, and the case is awaiting a hearing in the appellate court.
Raju argues that his office's workload has exploded and that the District Attorney's office is better funded than his.
It's true that the number of pending cases has grown, ironically in part because Raju keeps declining new clients, pushing cases to the back of the queue and swelling the backlog.
But new felony filings have been flat for four years. In fact, more felonies were filed in 2019, and there was never a work stoppage called then.
Misdemeanor filings have risen dramatically under District Attorney Brooke Jenkins. Still, a rising caseload is no excuse for the Public Defender to shirk his constitutional duty.
The District Attorney's budget is about 40% larger than the Public Defender's, and that may be a reasonable thing for the Mayor and the Board of Supervisors to debate. But there's a structural reason for the gap: private defense attorneys carry a significant share of the defense workload, which relieves pressure on the Public Defender's budget. There's no such thing as private criminal prosecution. All of that work falls to the District Attorney's office.
And remember: Judge Dorfman found that the Public Defender's office had attorneys available. Refusing new clients was a deliberate choice.
The Public Defender's seat is on the ballot this November, and Raju is running unopposed. That's a real shame. Even though he's the only name on the ballot, I won't be voting for him. I may skip the race, or I may write-in the name of an attorney friend. Either way, I’m not going to vote for someone who refuses to do the job he was elected to do.
Our city deserves a Public Defender who does the job well: one who provides a robust defense for everyone in San Francisco and strong leadership for the office. A Public Defender that fulfills the constitutional duty of the role.
As for what we can do about the situation as residents: tell your Supervisor that the next time Raju comes to them asking for more money for his office, they should demand that he commit to doing his job first, all five days of the week.
It's like that lesson I'm learning as a parent: you can't reward bad behavior. If the Public Defender wants more money, and perhaps his office does need it, he has to first show he's willing to fulfill the duty he swore to uphold.